Fruit juice, puree, and powder appear across one in six packaged foods, but these ingredients can function as hidden free sugars that current food labels may fail to disclose fully, according to a recent study published in Nutrition Bulletin.
News-Medical reported that 5,276 packaged food products were analyzed by scientists from the Federal University of Santa Catarina in Brazil, the University of New South Wales and Deakin University in Australia (including the George Institute for Global Health), and Universidad de la República in Uruguay.
The study used data from a store survey conducted in November 2020 at one of the 15 largest supermarket chains in Brazil, capturing label details via the FoodSwitch mobile application.
Dietary sugars in packaged foods are divided by origin, with added sugars added during manufacturing, cooking, or eating. Free sugars, as defined by the World Health Organization (WHO), also encompass sugars naturally present in fruit juices, syrups, and honey, with a recommendation to limit them to under 10% of daily energy.
Public Health England applies a broader definition that covers sugars in purees, pastes, and similar items where the fruit cell structure is broken down, while excluding dried or chopped fruit.
Applying this broader definition, the research team categorized extracts, puree, pulp, powdered fruit, and juices as fruit-based free sugar ingredients, or FBFS. The analysis found that 15.7% of the analyzed items declared at least one such ingredient. Nearly two-thirds of those products listed the fruit-based free sugar ingredient within the first three positions on their ingredient lists.
Processed fruit ingredients act as free sugars
- Hidden Sugars: Processed fruit ingredients like purees and juices break down the fruit’s natural cell structure, turning them into free sugars that behave similarly to added sugars in the body.
- Labeling Gaps: Current regulatory definitions in some regions exclude fruit juice, puree, and pulp from added sugar declarations, meaning shoppers may consume more free sugars than nutrition labels indicate.
- Dominant Categories: Fruit juice appeared most frequently in beverages and savory items, whereas puree and pulp dominated yogurts, sweet spreads, and plant-based dairy alternatives.
Prevalence across supermarket categories
The prevalence of fruit-based free sugar ingredients varied extensively across the 24 food groups examined in the study. All sampled juices, nectars, and fruit drinks contained these ingredients, alongside about 62% of fruit pieces, jams, and preserves.
Dairy drinks, yogurts, and dairy desserts listed fruit-based free sugar ingredients in 52% of cases, while sweet spreads registered a 48% prevalence. Savory snacks at 1.3% and gravies, sauces, and ready-to-eat dishes at 1.7% recorded the lowest rates among the categories evaluated.
The study identified 398 distinct terms describing fruit-related ingredients on packaging labels. Fruit juice was the most frequently declared FBFS category overall, followed closely by fruit puree and pulp, while powdered fruit and fruit extracts appeared much less frequently.
| Food Group | Analyzed Percentage Containing FBFS | Most Common Ingredient Type |
|---|---|---|
| Fruit Pieces and Jams | ~62% | Puree and Pulp |
| Dairy Drinks and Yogurts | ~52% | Puree and Pulp |
| Sweet Spreads | ~48% | Puree and Pulp |
| Savory Snacks | 1.3% | Dried or Chopped Fruit |
Research on fruit sugars and metabolic effects
Most research linking free sugars to conditions such as heart disease, type 2 diabetes, tooth decay, and obesity has focused on fructose-containing sugars like corn syrup. Evidence regarding sugars derived directly from fruit remains limited and contradictory, primarily restricted to fruit juice, while metabolic effects vary based on processing methods, sugar quantities, and the surrounding food matrix.
The survey in Brazil took place after new labeling rules were approved but before they officially took effect, establishing a baseline for subsequent comparisons. Brazil’s regulatory framework excludes fruit juice, puree, pulp, and powdered fruit from added sugar declarations. Consequently, labels displaying added sugar levels may underreport total free sugar content.
The study authors suggested that this regulatory distinction could encourage food manufacturers to substitute conventional added sugars with processed fruit ingredients, though the research did not track whether such substitution occurred. The findings also highlight potential vulnerabilities in front-of-pack nutrient profiling systems such as Nutri-Score and the Health Star Rating, which can assign positive nutritional values to certain processed fruit ingredients.
Contraindications & When to Consult a Doctor
The investigation did not measure the exact contribution of these processed fruit ingredients to total daily free sugar intake, nor did it directly examine their specific long-term health effects.
In 2026, Padovan and co-workers released their findings within Nutrition Bulletin, focusing on fruit constituents identified on Brazilian packaged food labels to classify processed fruit components that could potentially qualify as free sugars.
References
- Padovan, M., et al. (2026). The diversity of fruit‐based free sugar ingredients on food labels. Nutrition Bulletin. DOI:10.1111/nbu.70075