Hopkins Man Charged with Attempted Murder and Carjacking in Brutal Attack on Somali-American Uber Driver

Samit Apurva Patel, 25, was charged Tuesday in Hennepin County District Court with attempted second-degree murder and first-degree carjacking in the attack on Uber driver Mohamed Yusuf. The Somali American driver was found in a ditch in Hopkins, Minnesota, early Saturday, in a coma with a poor prognosis, according to the criminal complaint.

Yusuf suffered broken ribs, a broken leg, spinal injuries, collapsed lungs and internal bleeding from several organs, the complaint states. The internal bleeding was so severe that several organs had to be removed. He remained hospitalized as of Monday.

Here is why the case has drawn attention beyond the charges themselves. Community leaders called for a hate crime investigation, but prosecutors declined to pursue a bias enhancement.

Somali American Uber Driver in Coma: Attempted Murder Charge Filed in Hennepin County — WCCO – CBS Minnesota

Where the charges stand

  • Patel is charged with attempted second-degree murder and first-degree carjacking; each count carries a maximum sentence of 20 years, per the complaint.
  • Bail is set at $1 million; his first court appearance is scheduled for 1:30 p.m. Wednesday, per the Hennepin County Attorney’s Office.
  • Prosecutors say evidence does not support a bias-motivation enhancement; Uber has banned the rider from its platform.

What the phone call recorded

The complaint reconstructs the attack partly through a phone call that stayed connected throughout. Uber records show Yusuf picked up Patel at 12:47 a.m. Saturday near a bar in northeast Minneapolis, according to the complaint. Yusuf was speaking with his brother, also an Uber driver, and the call stayed connected.

The brother reported hearing Patel ask Yusuf what his name was. Patel then said, “I do not like that name.”

Yusuf’s son, Mustafa Osman, told The Somali Brief that his father “was run over multiple times with his own vehicle.” Yusuf’s cousin, Abdinasir Ali, told the outlet the passenger asked the driver’s name and said “I do not like that name” before attacking him.

The GPS trail to the ditch

Uber’s GPS data fills in the route.

Time (Saturday) Event per the complaint
12:47 a.m. Yusuf picks up Patel near a northeast Minneapolis bar
1:05 a.m. Vehicle stops several minutes near the Hopkins Gravel Pits entrance
1:07 a.m. SUV crosses northbound lanes into a ditch; leaves 20 seconds later
~1:20 a.m. Police sent to Patel’s home for a welfare check

The welfare check that ended the drive

It had damage to the front and rear, with dirt and burs inside.

Patel was incoherent and visibly distressed, the complaint says. He asked officers to arrest him, and his clothing was covered in burs. He first claimed the SUV was his, then acknowledged it wasn’t.

Officers located an injured adult male near Hopkins Crossroad and Minnetonka Boulevard.

Hopkins uber attack
Photo: fox9.com

Why no bias enhancement

Minnesota doesn’t have a separate hate crime statute. However, bias motivation can be used as a sentencing enhancement.

Hennepin County Attorney Mary Moriarty said her office reviewed the evidence on motive before filing charges.

“All we really have was Mr. Yusuf’s brother conveying that the conversation that he heard,” Moriarty said at a Tuesday news conference, according to FOX 9. “If additional evidence comes in, we’ll take a look at that.”

She added that motive is difficult to prove. “So we don’t have a motive right now.”

What Uber and the community have said

Uber said Monday it banned the rider from its platform. Muslim leaders called Monday for the FBI to investigate the case, per FOX 9. The complaint doesn’t state a motive and doesn’t include a bias-related charge.

But the balance of the record still leaves the question open. Moriarty said that if Patel is convicted, prosecutors can still ask for a sentence that reflects the brutality of the offense.

His first court appearance is scheduled for 1:30 p.m. Wednesday, according to the Hennepin County Attorney’s Office.

Disclaimer: The information provided in this article is for educational and informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice.

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

GSK Won US Accelerated Approval on Tuesday for Nelkarmi