Ireland fly-half Sam Prendergast has been cleared to face South Africa in Dublin this Saturday after an independent disciplinary committee dismissed his citing for a hip-drop tackle on Fiji captain Peceli Yato, the first such citing since World Rugby outlawed the manoeuvre on November 1.
The 23-year-old appeared before a three-person panel on Tuesday evening, less than a week after Ireland’s win over Fiji in the Nations Championship. The committee — Mike Hamlin (chair) and Becky Essex of England, and Australia’s Wayne Erickson — unanimously determined that Prendergast had, to the required standard, proved the citing should be dismissed, according to a Nations Championship statement.
That outcome was no surprise to one man in particular. South Africa head coach Rassie Erasmus had predicted it a day earlier — while simultaneously stoking a feud that has now cost him six Tests.
“Erasmus went on to make extraordinary claims, saying” South Africa head coach Rassie Erasmus said.

“We are in the northern hemisphere. I think there is going to be a technicality and he is going to play.”
Erasmus told reporters in Dublin on Monday. He called Prendergast’s tackle “terrible” and said he believed it should have been an “immediate red card” during the Fiji match. Irish management were frustrated by those remarks; they believed the tackle never met the red-card threshold. The committee agreed with them.
A law three weeks old
Here is why the case carried such weight: hip-drop tackles — where a tackler drops his hips and bodyweight onto the ball-carrier’s legs — were only outlawed by World Rugby before this month’s internationals. Prendergast’s challenge on Yato, which left the Fiji centre limping off, went unpunished on the field. A citing commissioner then reviewed the footage and judged it worthy of a red card, triggering the hearing under Law 9.13.
The precedent matters because no player had been cited under the new offence before. Detailed findings and reasons will follow in the committee’s written judgment — the document that will effectively teach the rugby world how this law will be policed.

Prendergast, who regained his place in July after Jack Crowley’s long-term leg injury and started both of Ireland’s Tests this month against Argentina and Fiji, struggled off the kicking tee against Fiji. He is now expected to continue at number 10 on Saturday evening.
World Rugby bans Erasmus six Tests
The Springboks coach could not enjoy the outcome for long. World Rugby has banned him for six Tests, effective immediately, after he questioned whether the officiating in South Africa’s 21-19 defeat by France in Paris last Friday amounted to match-fixing — calling it “an unacceptable attack on the credibility and competence of the match officials.” SA Rugby have since requested a formal hearing.
“I’m saying if he didn’t see it, it must be a technology problem. If he saw it and decided not to act on it, is that not match-fixing?”
Erasmus said, targeting television match official Matteo Liperini. He also claimed France got away with 17 hip-drops or knee-drops in Paris. His grievances extend to Ireland prop Tadhg Furlong avoiding punishment for an alleged groin grab — while South Africa’s Jan-Hendrik Wessels received a nine-match ban for a similar offence last year.
| Case | Outcome | When |
|---|---|---|
| Sam Prendergast (hip-drop citing) | Dismissed unanimously | Tuesday, November 17 |
| Rassie Erasmus (match-fixing comments) | Six-Test ban, immediate effect | Announced this week |
| Jan-Hendrik Wessels (similar offence) | Nine-match ban | Last year |
| Erasmus, Nic Berry video leak | Banned | 2021 |
But there is a catch for the Springboks’ camp: Erasmus has form. He was banned for leaking an hour-long video dissecting referee Nic Berry’s performance after a British and Irish Lions Test in 2021, and posted videos questioning Wayne Barnes’ decisions after a France defeat the following year. Both Berry and Barnes have since spoken about the abuse they received.
Ironically, the guidance on television match officials — to intervene only for clear and obvious foul play — was itself agreed with head coaches, Erasmus included. The panel that cleared Prendergast applied exactly that standard: the tackle wrapped around Yato’s legs, but Ireland successfully argued it did not meet the red-card threshold.
Saturday’s meeting in Dublin now proceeds with both storylines intact: a fly-half freed by a fresh law’s first real test, and a rival coach watching from the stands under suspension, his formal hearing still to come. As the Nations Championship statement put it, the committee “unanimously determined that the player had, to the required standard, proved that the citing should be dismissed.”
Earlier coverage: Sam Prendergast Cleared to Play Against South Africa