Giampaolo Amato faces a definitive life sentence following the Supreme Court of Cassazione’s rejection of his defense team’s appeal regarding the October 2021 murders of his wife and mother-in-law.
The definitive ruling brings closure to a judicial marathon concerning the deaths of 62-year-old gynaecologist Isabella Linsalata and her 87-year-old mother, Giulia Tateo, in Bologna, Il Resto del Carlino reported, according to Ansa. The victims were discovered in their communicating apartments on via Bianconi twenty-two days apart, initially appearing to have died from natural causes before forensic investigations uncovered a lethal pharmaceutical combination.
The First Penal Section of the Supreme Court of Cassazione issued the final verdict on a Wednesday evening after nearly seven hours in the council chamber, rejecting the arguments brought by defense attorneys Valerio Spigarelli and Franco Coppi. The prosecution, represented by Deputy Prosecutor General Simone Perelli, maintained throughout the hearing that the judgments from both the initial trial and the appellate court were procedurally unassailable.
“[T]he impugned sentence is procedurally unassailable,” Simone Perelli told the court during his morning requisition, noting that the verdict rested on a multiplicity of grave and concordant elements.
The core evidence established during the trial centered on the administration of a precise pharmaceutical mix consisting of Sevoflurane, a potent halogenated ether inhalational anesthetic, and Midazolam, a short-acting benzodiazepine central nervous system depressant. Forensic pathologists demonstrated that this targeted combination induced rapid respiratory depression and central nervous system suppression.

Investigators initially treated the October 9, 2021, death of Giulia Tateo as natural, but the subsequent death of Isabella Linsalata on the night between October 30 and October 31 triggered autopsies and toxicology screens. Authorities arrested Amato on April 8, 2023, after toxicology reports confirmed the presence of the anesthetic agents, leading prosecutors to describe the initial death as a trial run for the subsequent homicide.
| Victim | Age | Date of Death | Administered Agents |
|---|---|---|---|
| Giulia Tateo | 87 | October 9, 2021 | Sevoflurane & Midazolam |
| Isabella Linsalata | 62 | October 31, 2021 | Sevoflurane & Midazolam |
, according to Il Resto del Carlino
Sevoflurane and Midazolam Combination Indicates Deliberate Poisoning
- Anesthetic Vulnerability: Sevoflurane is an operating room anesthetic that requires specialized administration and airway monitoring; its presence outside a clinical setting indicates deliberate poisoning.
- Benzodiazepine Effects: Midazolam slows brain activity and breathing, creating profound sedation that can be fatal when combined with inhaled anesthetics without medical supervision.
- Forensic Toxicology: Blood and tissue screenings remain the definitive method for detecting volatile anesthetics and sedatives long after death.
Court Characterized Crimes as Egoistic Iterative Homicides
Judges in the Bologna Assize Court of Appeal characterized the crimes as iterative homicides driven exclusively by egoistic motivations, noting that the perpetrator executed the plan with exceptional coldness and cunning, according to ansa.it. The prosecution established a dual motive involving Amato’s desire to pursue a relationship with a younger woman and financial interests tied to his wife’s considerable estate.

The defense argued that the motive was illogical and contested the absence of an independent court-appointed forensic review during the appellate proceedings, sassarinotizie.com reported. Despite these objections, the Supreme Court upheld the first-degree life sentence issued on October 16, 2024, and the appellate confirmation handed down on January 9, 2026.
Throughout the proceedings, Amato maintained his innocence while detained. Family dynamics remained complex; the couple’s adult children, Anna Chiara and Nicola, maintained their father’s innocence. Nicola Amato publicly asserted that direct proof was lacking and that the judicial case should remain open, lamilano.it reported.
Ruling Concludes Landmark Case on Medical Drug Misuse
The ruling concludes a landmark case regarding the misuse of hospital-restricted pharmaceutical agents by a medical professional. The case shows how forensic toxicology is critical to identifying deaths caused by drugs that look like natural causes.
The Supreme Court of Cassazione, seated in Rome’s Palace of Justice, is Italy’s highest court of appeal and ensures uniform application of law across the judiciary. Established under the 1865 Civil Code and reorganized by royal decree in 1941, it hears cases in panels of five judges, or nine in complex matters, and its confirmations are final and cannot be further appealed on the same grounds.
The sentence represents the definitive conclusion of judicial reviews in the Italian legal system for this proceeding.
References
Earlier coverage: Italy's Top Court Upholds Life Sentence for Ex-Doctor Who Poisoned Wife, Mother-in-Law