Johnny Gargano Eyes Grayson Waller, EK Prosper for John Cena Classic

“Oh boy, there’s a lot of great talent in NXT. I have a long history with the current NXT Champion, Grayson Waller, who has gone down to NXT and done absolutely fantastic work,” Johnny Gargano told TV Insider, confirming his desire to represent SmackDown in the inaugural John Cena Classic on December 14 at Disney World.

The tournament, assembled with input from John Cena himself, pits Raw, SmackDown, and NXT talent against one another in a brand-versus-brand format. Gargano, a former NXT Champion, named Waller and rising prospect EK Prosper as preferred opponents, Wrestling Attitude reported. The card already features Cody Rhodes, Zilla Fatu, and Noam Dar, per Fightful.

Grayson waller defeats ek prosper on wwe nxt
Photo: wrestlezone.com
  • Gargano/Waller rematch carries built-in narrative equity from their 2023 Unsanctioned Match and 2024 DIY vs. A-Town Down Under program.

Gargano’s interest in Waller is not merely brand warfare. The pair collided in an Unsanctioned Match at NXT Stand & Deliver 2023, where Waller emerged victorious, and crossed paths again during the 2024 feud between #DIY and A-Town Down Under, Fightful noted. That layered history—spanning singles brutality and tag-team chess—gives a potential Classic meeting immediate stakes most first-time crossovers lack.

While Waller provides the narrative hook, Gargano’s unprompted mention of EK Prosper reveals scouting diligence. “I can mention a guy like EK Prosper, who I’ve seen that has impressed me down there as well,” Gargano said. Gargano’s inclusion of Prosper on his wish list accelerates his timeline toward a main-roster audition.

The December 14 date at Disney World aligns with WWE’s expanded entertainment partnership, per WrestleZone. John Cena’s direct involvement in participant selection suggests the company views the Classic as a tentpole for the streaming calendar.

Metric Gargano Waller Prosper
Brand SmackDown NXT (Champion) NXT
Tag Program Overlap 2024 (#DIY vs. A-Town Down Under) 2024 (#DIY vs. A-Town Down Under) None
Classic Status Campaigning for spot Presumed NXT rep Dark horse candidate

Official brackets have not been released. Gargano must secure a SmackDown qualifying slot, while Waller’s NXT Championship reign likely guarantees entry. The next SmackDown taping cycle will clarify whether Creative books a qualifying angle or grants Gargano a direct berth.

Gargano began his career in 2005 with Cleveland All–Pro Wrestling and became a mainstay of the American independent circuit, capturing Dragon Gate USA’s Open the Freedom Gate Championship twice — the first reign lasting a record 873 days.

After signing with WWE in April 2016, he formed #DIY with Tommaso Ciampa and became the inaugural NXT Triple Crown champion in April 2019. He left the company in December 2021 before returning to the main roster in August 2022, later reuniting #DIY to win the WWE Tag Team Championship in July and December 2024.

Johnny gargano wwe nxt
Photo: fightful.com

Disclaimer: The fantasy and market insights provided are for informational and entertainment purposes only and do not constitute financial or betting advice.

Photo of author

Sport Desk

Sport Desk at Archyde.

Musk at DealBook: Not MAGA, Regrets Future Midterm Spending, Accuses Zelenskyy of Lying