Justice Dept. Moves to Dismiss Lawsuit Seeking to Delay Peltola Certification

Federal attorneys moved on Thursday to dismiss a lawsuit that sought to block the certification of Democrat Mary Peltola’s U.S. Senate victory in Alaska.

The Justice Department filed documents in the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals stating that the case has become moot following the conclusion of the election, according to AP News. The legal challenge, launched at President Donald Trump’s direction, aimed to delay certification until investigators could determine whether voters were confused by a second ballot candidate sharing the name of incumbent Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan.

Peltola secured an outright majority in the race, giving Democrats their 56th seat in the upcoming Congress, as reported by NPR. Because she surpassed the 50 percent threshold on first-choice votes, the state avoided using its ranked-choice voting system, rendering the votes cast for the second candidate inconsequential to the final outcome.

“The United States therefore reluctantly acknowledges that there no longer exists any means of determining whether votes cast for Daniel J. Sullivan were meant to be cast for Senator Sullivan,” Justice Department attorneys wrote in their filing, as noted by Alaska Beacon.

In the new filing, government lawyers urged the appeals court to vacate the lower court’s dismissal and remand the case for a straight dismissal on mootness grounds, erasing the initial loss from the record. The Alaska state government, controlled by Republicans, had previously opposed the administration’s legal efforts, filing papers to help defeat what state officials called a meritless challenge.

Justice Dept. Moves to Dismiss Lawsuit Seeking to Delay Peltola Certification
Photo: NPR

Federal and state investigators, including the FBI and the Alaska Bureau of Investigation, have continued examining the recruitment of the second candidate, Daniel J. Sullivan Jr., a retired schoolteacher from Petersburg. Meanwhile, Alaska Division of Elections Director Carol Beecher said that the state intends to proceed with certifying Peltola’s victory next week.

The high-stakes electoral showdown brought intense national attention to the state’s voting process, culminating in a historic victory for Peltola. Her triumph marks the first time a Democrat has claimed a U.S. Senate seat in Alaska in more than ten years, ending a long period of Republican dominance in that specific office.

outside the White House

In addition to shifting the partisan balance in the upper chamber of Congress, the outcome contributes to the Democratic Party’s largest Senate majority since 2011, establishing a 56-to-44 advantage when the new legislative session convenes in early January.

Before the race was officially called, public discourse was heavily dominated by arguments over the appearance of the second candidate on the ballot. The Alaska Supreme Court had previously affirmed that the retired Petersburg teacher was legally qualified to appear on the ballot without a party preference, listed as Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. to differentiate him from the two-term incumbent senator.

Mary Peltola Closes in on 50% Threshold in Alaska Senate Race
Photo: Newsweek

However, controversy erupted after reporting from The New York Times indicated that people associated with Peltola’s campaign and other Democratic operatives had worked to recruit him to contest the seat. Peltola consistently denied any personal involvement or wrongdoing regarding the recruitment scheme.

President Trump seized upon the reports of the second candidate, publicly declaring the situation to be a massive electoral fraud effort. He demanded that Peltola face criminal prosecution and be removed from the ballot, while federal investigators deployed to Alaska before Election Day.

Following the initial emergence of these allegations, the Department of Justice initiated a civil lawsuit requesting a federal judge to prevent the state from certifying any election loss suffered by Senator Sullivan. U.S. District Court Judge Sharon Gleason ultimately rejected the administration’s plea, ruling that the federal government lacked standing and dismissing the case on November 1.

The legal battle continued on appeal before the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, where the federal government faced fierce pushback from advocacy organizations. Attorneys representing the American Civil Liberties Union, on behalf of the League of Women Voters of Alaska and the national organization Common Cause, condemned the government’s arguments in legal filings.

They urged the appellate court to uphold Judge Gleason’s dismissal swiftly and to order federal attorneys to show cause as to why they should not face sanctions for pursuing a frivolous legal challenge. The ACLU attorneys characterized the federal legal theory as embarrassing and indefensible.

Despite the contentious legal maneuvers and public accusations, the actual vote tallies eventually neutralized the controversy. Election analysts and constitutional law experts said that Alaska’s unique ranked-choice voting structure inherently mitigated potential voter confusion, as people who might have mistakenly marked the wrong name could have easily corrected their preferences by ranking both candidates.

Ultimately, Peltola secured an outright majority of first-choice ballots, garnering over 140,000 votes, which safely surpassed the threshold needed to avoid secondary redistribution rounds. Her vote total exceeded the combined count received by her main Republican opponent and the independent namesake candidate.

Mary peltola ww
Photo: NBC News

Throughout the campaign, Peltola focused heavily on bread-and-butter issues while working within the state’s complex political setup. As a Yup’ik Alaskan, she made history in 2022 by winning a special election for the state’s lone U.S. House of Representatives seat following the passing of longtime Republican Rep. Don Young, becoming the first Alaska Native to serve in Congress.

Although she lost her subsequent House reelection bid in 2024 to Republican challenger Nick Begich, her statewide Senate campaign leaned into her Indigenous identity, cultural representation, and community roots. She framed her platform around economic affordability, healthcare costs, domestic energy jobs, border security, and gun rights, while openly criticizing her opponent over alleged corruption.

“Alaska is a very small population, with a very, very large landmass, so it's very important that you try to build up, across that large landmass, ties and community ties” Scott Lucas, a professor of international politics at University College Dublin's Clinton Institute, told Al Jazeera.

Alaska is the largest U.S. state by area, larger than Texas, California, and Montana combined, yet it ranks third-least populous with 740,133 residents in 2024. Purchased from the Russian Empire in 1867 for $7.2 million, it became the 49th state on January 3, 1959.

U.S. Senate candidate Mary Peltola met with supporters at a campaign event at 49th State Brewing Company on October 21
Photo: Anchorage Daily News

It holds the distinction of being the northernmost, westernmost, and longitudinally easternmost state, bordering Canada to the east and sharing a maritime border with Russia in the Bering Strait. Approximately 22 percent of its population identifies as Native American, the highest proportion of any state.

Political scientists and regional observers said that Peltola’s appeal extended far beyond traditional partisan alignments, capitalizing on local dissatisfaction with incumbent policies and economic pressures. The political climate proved challenging for Republican incumbents nationwide, compounded by dipping approval ratings for the Trump administration and local angst over high fuel prices.

While Senator Sullivan’s campaign attempted to blame external geopolitical conflicts for economic hardships, voters gravitated toward alternative leadership. Senate Democratic Leader Chuck Schumer said in a public statement that the party’s final tally of 56 Senate seats was an extraordinary milestone that far exceeded expectations set months before.

Earlier coverage: Justice Department Asks Court to Dismiss Alaska Senate Lawsuit as Moot

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

Italy’s Supreme Court Upholds Life Sentence for Ex-Doctor Who Killed Wife, Mother-in-Law with Drug Cocktail