Justice Department Asks Court to Dismiss Alaska Senate Lawsuit as Moot

The Justice Department spent weeks trying to stop Alaska from certifying a Senate result it feared. On Thursday, two days after the race was called, it gave up.

The department asked the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals to declare its lawsuit against Alaska moot, conceding in a filing that “there no longer exists any means” of determining whether votes cast for a second candidate named Dan Sullivan were meant for the incumbent Republican senator. The concession effectively ends an effort, ordered by President Trump, that threatened to keep Senator-elect Mary Peltola, a Democrat, from taking office.

Mr. Trump had directed the Justice Department to sue before Election Day, arguing Alaska should not certify a narrow Peltola victory until investigators could rule out voter confusion between Senator Dan S. Sullivan and a retired schoolteacher, Dan J. Sullivan of Petersburg, listed on the ballot without party preference.

Instead, Peltola won by more than four percentage points — a margin so wide that the incumbent would have lost even if every ballot cast for the lesser-known Sullivan had gone to him.

“Now that the election is over and the voters sent a very clear message about the direction they want our state to go in, I’m eager to move forward and get to work on behalf of all Alaskans,” Peltola said in a statement responding to Thursday’s filing. “For Alaskans, there is only one direction: forward.”

The Associated Press called the race for Peltola on Tuesday, making her the ninth Senate pickup for Democrats in a midterm outcome that flipped control of Congress. Her victory gave Democrats their 56th senator in the next Congress.

Justice Department seeks to vacate dismissal

The Thursday filing came from Stanley E. Woodward, the Justice Department’s third-ranked official. It asked the appeals court to do something unusual: vacate the district court’s dismissal of the lawsuit — erasing the loss on the record — and then dismiss the case anyway as moot.

“This Court should deny the motion to summarily affirm the district court’s judgment,” Woodward wrote. “Instead, this Court should vacate the district court’s order dismissing this lawsuit, because the case has become moot.”

Woodward wrote that the United States “reluctantly” acknowledged there was no longer any way to determine whether votes cast for Daniel J. Sullivan were meant for the senator. The reason is mechanical rather than legal: ballots have been de-identified, so no one can question voters about their reasoning, the filing shows.

That problem was visible long before Election Day. The administration never explained how such an investigation could take place given the secrecy of the ballot. A federal judge in Alaska denied the Justice Department’s request to segregate ballots cast for Dan J. Sullivan, then threw out the lawsuit on Nov. 1, saying there was “no workable plan” to investigate the claims.

The decoy candidate at the center of it

The suit turned on a quirk of Alaska politics that is older than either candidate: two people named Dan Sullivan on the same ballot. The second Sullivan, a retired teacher from the small fishing community of Petersburg, ran as Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. with no party preference, distinguished from the senator, who was listed as a Republican and the incumbent.

The New York Times reported that Democrats helped recruit the second candidate, citing texts and other documents that appeared to show Peltola’s campaign was involved. Dan J. Sullivan has long insisted he ran on his own, and Peltola has denied any involvement, saying she was “not interested in tricking voters.” Peltola has said she was unaware of the plan to recruit a spoiler.

In October, the Justice Department announced an investigation into the Democrats who recruited the decoy candidate, sending letters to 20 people informing them they might be targets or asking them to preserve records, and issuing hundreds of subpoenas, according to a person familiar with the investigation who spoke on condition of anonymity to The New York Times.

Prosecutors acknowledged that inquiry might never yield criminal charges. Thursday’s filings did not address its status. Tricks involving decoy candidates have been a staple of U.S. politics for decades, and Mr. Trump’s allies have used them too, though occasionally such schemes do lead to criminal charges.

Even Alaska’s Republican leadership balked

Alaska’s government is controlled by Republicans, who hold the governorship and the Legislature, yet the state’s lawyers sought to have the case dismissed, calling the suit legally meritless. The Alaska Supreme Court had already ruled that the second Sullivan’s candidacy was legal and he could remain on the ballot.

Alaska’s Republican Gov. Mike Dunleavy ordered a separate investigation into Peltola’s campaign after the Times report, and before Election Day the Justice Department’s top prosecutor in Alaska called the reporting “troubling.”

This was at least the second time since the Nov. 3 election that the department moved to dismiss one of its high-profile lawsuits interfering in states’ handling of elections.

Peltola, who was born in Anchorage in 1973 and is Yup’ik from the Yukon–Kuskokwim Delta, first entered Congress in August 2022, winning a special election after the death of the longtime incumbent Don Young by defeating Sarah Palin and Nick Begich III in an upset.

In doing so she became the first Alaska Native member of Congress, the first woman to represent Alaska in the House, and the first Democrat to hold the seat since Nick Begich Sr. in 1972.

Before her congressional career, she served a decade in the Alaska House of Representatives, sat on the Orutsararmiut Native Council’s tribal court as a judge, and worked as executive director of the Kuskokwim River Inter-Tribal Fish Commission.

The judge could still rule on the merits of the case even though the department argues the point is moot. Senator Sullivan’s campaign did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping’ Review: Better Than ‘Songbirds & Snakes,’ But Still a Meandering Slog

ONE Championship Doubleheader: Imangazaliev vs. Ortikov Title Rematch Headlines Grand Prix Quarterfinals at Lumpinee Stadium