Senate GOP Advances FCC Nominee 15-0 After Democrats Boycott Vote

The Senate Commerce Committee voted 15 to 0 on Wednesday to advance Danielle Thumann, President Donald Trump’s nominee for the Federal Communications Commission, after all 13 Democrats on the panel boycotted the session to deny a quorum.

Chairman Ted Cruz (R-Texas) proceeded with a Republican-only vote anyway, and every one of the committee’s 15 Republicans approved the nomination. The committee’s rules normally require at least one minority-party member to be present for a vote on a nomination, but Cruz’s office argued Senate rules let the nomination move to the full chamber regardless.

Thumann, named in some coverage as Danielle Thumann Severs, was nominated in August for one of two open seats on the five-member commission, where she already serves as a senior counsel to FCC Chairman Brendan Carr. Her confirmation matters now because Republicans want her seated before Democrats take Senate control in January.

At the hearing, Cruz framed the vote as duty over procedure. “We’re going to be doing our job today, even if the Democrats refuse to show up to do theirs,” Cruz said. He also criticized the boycott directly, saying Republicans had not boycotted hearings when Democrats ran the committee under President Joe Biden, and warned that Washington faces two years of total obstruction once the chamber changes hands.

The quorum rule Democrats say Cruz broke

The fight is technically procedural, and it turns on committee rules that may not technically exist right now. A spokesperson for Sen. Maria Cantwell (D-Wash.), the committee’s top Democrat, said that “since 2005, Commerce Committee rules required that a quorum include one member of the minority for official action on bill, resolution, or nomination.”

But the committee has operated with no formally adopted rules during Cruz’s chairmanship, the spokesperson said, because Cruz failed to pass committee rules for the current session of Congress. In practice, the spokesperson said, it has still followed the last Congress’s rules, including the minority-presence provision. “Until today,” the spokesperson added.

Cruz’s office countered that Senate rules allow a nomination to be advanced for a vote by the whole chamber even without the minority present.

Why Democrats stayed home

Democrats on the committee said in a statement that they oppose the nomination and had sought to deny Republicans a quorum for the vote. Led by Cantwell, they argued the Severs nomination should be paired with another term for Commissioner Anna Gomez, the commission’s sole Democrat, saying the partisan imbalance is not a problem of their making but one the White House can solve.

The commission's calculations explain their bargaining power. The FCC currently has two Republicans and one Democrat, and the law allows no more than three of the five commissioners from the same party. Seating Thumann would make it three Republicans and one Democrat, with two seats still vacant and no Democratic counterpart nominated.

The false testimony allegation hanging over the vote

The nomination is also entangled with the fight over Jimmy Kimmel. At a hearing last week, Sen. Ben Ray Luján (D-N.M.) asked Thumann, “Do you support Chairman Carr’s illegal campaign to remove Jimmy Kimmel from the nation’s airwaves?”

“I have not worked with the chairman on any media-related issues,” Thumann replied. That answer is now the basis of accusations that she gave false testimony about her work as Carr’s legal advisor, since her day job is senior counsel to the chairman himself.

Luján has also said he expects Carr to be called to appear at least monthly next year, accusing the FCC chair of evading questions. Last year, lawmakers called for Carr’s resignation after he pressured Disney over Kimmel’s late-night show, and a federal judge has yet to rule on Disney’s bid to block an early license review of eight ABC stations that was ordered in April.

What happens at the full Senate

The nomination now heads to the Senate floor, where it needs majority approval. The timing is the whole point: Republicans are pushing to confirm Thumann before Democrats take chamber control in January, which would otherwise give the minority party real bargaining power over FCC confirmations.

What remains unresolved is whether the committee’s vote itself holds up. Cantwell’s office maintains the action violated the quorum practice in place since 2005; Cruz’s office maintains Senate rules authorize the advancement regardless. Neither side has budged, and the judge’s ruling on the ABC license review is still pending.

Photo of author

Technology Desk

Technology Desk at Archyde.

Boosting Brain Protein SORLA Reduces Toxic Tau Tangles and Protects Synapses in Mice

Cadillac Keeps Valtteri Bottas for 2027 F1 Season, Passes Over Colton Herta