The Haymitch Abernathy origin story has arrived in theaters, and the verdict from early reviews is a split decision: better than the last one, but still a slog.
“The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping,” the second prequel drawn from Suzanne Collins’ dystopian novels, opens this week with critics calling it a watchable if meandering return to Panem — an improvement over 2023’s widely panned “The Ballad of Songbirds & Snakes,” yet a film that replays familiar ground at a lumbering two hours and 38 minutes.
Directed by Francis Lawrence, the new film adapts the second of Collins’ two prequel novels and traces how a 16-year-old Haymitch — the character Woody Harrelson played as a drunken, gone-to-seed former champion in the original series — becomes the victor of the 50th Hunger Games, known as the Second Quarter Quell.
According to a review carried by Variety, the film is “meandering and more than a bit thin,” but it has been shot in the lavish mode of surface intensity that might now be called Hunger Games Classic.
The bar was low. Variety’s review described “Songbirds & Snakes” — the story of a young Coriolanus Snow — as a “stilted, cumbersome travesty” that scored at the box office but arrived as “a prequel without psychology, momentum, or dramatic sense.” Against that measure, critics agree the new film clears it.

Not everyone is fully sold. A review published by recorderonline.com credits the film with getting “a lot right,” including a “class in casting younger versions of familiar characters,” before delivering a blunt verdict of its own: “But, man, it’s a slog.” That review also argues the movie essentially repackages what audiences have already seen, where “Songbirds & Snakes” at least felt fresh.
Joseph Zada steps into Haymitch’s boots
Joseph Zada plays the teenage Haymitch, a resident of District 12, Panem’s poorest region, with a loving family and a devoted sweetheart, Lenore Dove Baird, played by Whitney Peak. Variety’s reviewer found the casting plausible in a way the previous prequel’s was not: while it was “impossible to believe” that Tom Blyth could grow into the sinister President Snow, Zada — with what the review calls his two-tone curly blond hair and blue-eyed stare of earnest valor — can half-convince as a younger version of Harrelson’s dissolute champion.
For much of the film, though, the reviewer suggests he plays the young warrior as pin-up.
Haymitch is not originally chosen as a tribute for the 50th Games, a supersized edition featuring twice as many competitors. Fate intervenes, and he becomes one of District 12’s four tributes after trying, valiantly, to save the reluctant tribute initially picked.
The reaping — which falls, grimly, on Haymitch’s birthday every year — is singled out by Variety as one of the movie’s better scenes, with several violent surprises and Glenn Close having “a debauched good time” as Drusilla Sickle, the Capitol escort who presents like a regal cosmetic-surgery victim on her way to the Met Gala.
The supporting cast is crowded with younger versions of established figures. Kieran Culkin takes on the young Caesar Flickerman, formerly Stanley Tucci’s flamboyant television host — Variety calls Culkin fine, if not nearly as stylishly depraved as Tucci. Jesse Plemons plays Plutarch Heavensbee, the cameraman role originated by the late Philip Seymour Hoffman, whose job is to broadcast but whose essential task is to edit what viewers see at home — quietly encouraging Haymitch to revolt.
Ralph Fiennes takes over as President Snow, closer in age to Donald Sutherland’s incarnation than to Blyth’s, per the recorderonline.com review, which also notes Elle Fanning as Effie Trinket, Maya Hawke as Wiress, Lili Taylor as Mags, and Kelvin Harrison Jr. as Beetee, who draws Haymitch into a covert plot.

One structural problem haunts the franchise’s prequels, as Variety’s review puts it: they chart the “evolution” of a dystopia that is already a dystopia. How much of a thrill is it, the reviewer asks, to watch things slide from bad to a little bit worse?
The film clamps down on its own drama, too — Haymitch’s devotion to Lenore Dove means he is never tempted into flirtation with fellow tribute Maysilee Donner, played by Mckenna Grace, leaving the fascist media politics as the story’s real engine.
The Second Quarter Quell supplies the spectacle. Tributes are fed into a sunlit paradise that looks, per Variety, like the Shire attached to a madly colorful Disney forest, and the arena’s hazards include an erupting volcano and an array of mechanical creatures — glittery blue butterflies that can electrocute, killer rabbits, and red birds that attack like something out of “The Birds.”
After Haymitch wins the Games — not a spoiler, as the review reminds novices — the film’s distended final section turns to his tragedy and his devolution into the man Harrelson will play 24 years later. A sunlit epilogue featuring unnamed famous actors reassures the audience that it is all good.
Lawrence, born in 1971 in Vienna, Austria, to American parents, came to directing by way of music videos, working with stars including Britney Spears, Jay-Z and Lady Gaga — and winning a Grammy Award in 2011 for Lady Gaga’s “Bad Romance.”
His feature debut was the superhero thriller “Constantine” in 2005, followed by “I Am Legend” in 2007. He took over the “Hunger Games” franchise in 2012, directing “Catching Fire” and both “Mockingjay” parts before signing on for the prequels, making him the series’ longest-serving director.
Whether the franchise ends here
Reviews land while the film is in theaters this week, giving Lionsgate’s franchise a softer critical landing than its predecessor received. Variety’s reviewer closes with a condition attached to that goodwill: the assessment holds, the review states, “As long as there are no more prequels to ‘The Hunger Games.’”
Whether the studio treats this as an ending or another sunrise remains the open question the film’s reception now hangs on.
Worth a look