The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping hits theaters this weekend with early critics calling it gripping while fans brace for tears, and Being Heumann lands on Apple TV as a two-and-a-half-star crowd-pleaser.
One rewrites a tragedy we already know; the other rescues a civil-rights battle from obscurity.
Vail Daily’s long-running “Movie Guru” column graded it three stars out of four, praising Joseph Zada’s young Haymitch as a performance that will win your heart before he breaks it.
Vulture’s review frames it bluntly: the best thing about the film is that it delivers good old-fashioned Hunger Gaming, the first proper arena battle in over a decade.
The New York premiere of #TheHungerGames: Sunrise on the Reaping. pic.twitter.com/xMMt3uKLGl
What the critics actually say
The Vail Daily review calls the story a story that still needs to be told, arguing the Capitol’s glitz reads even more garish, given the horrors, and that the film’s young hero wins through sheer sweetness and intensity.
Vulture, by contrast, leads with the action: electrified butterflies, man-eating squirrels, toxic pollen, a conveniently placed volcano. That outlet also flags a rough edge the Vail Daily review never mentions — Zada’s unfortunate drawl he sporadically attempts, which the Vulture critic compares unfavorably to Woody Harrelson’s coherence in the role.
Both, though, land on the same show-stealer. Vulture singles out Kieran Culkin as Caesar Flickerman, writing that he feels like he’s already been doing Caesar for years. The Vail Daily review splits its praise differently, naming Mackenna Grace “excellent” in an angry, determined turn and calling Jesse Plemons “fantastic” as the coolly calculating Plutarch Heavensbee.
Sixty years of Panem, on one page
Per Vulture, the story picks up four decades after The Ballad of Songbirds & Snakes, which reached screens in 2023, and a quarter-century before the original Hunger Games — with Haymitch, at sixteen, reaped into the 50th annual Games after shielding his girlfriend Lenore Dove (Whitney Peak) from Panem’s storm troopers.
| Film | Position in saga | Year noted by sources |
|---|---|---|
| The Ballad of Songbirds & Snakes | Earliest prequel; small, primitive arena | 2023 |
| Sunrise on the Reaping | Four decades after Songbirds; the 50th Games | In theaters now |
| The original trilogy | Quarter-century after the Reaping | Concluded over a decade ago; Mockingjay – Part 2 arrived in 2015 |
The catch: the deck is stacked. As Vulture notes, we know Haymitch survives — “he has to become Woody Harrelson.” The Vail Daily review turns that same foreknowledge into an asset, writing that knowing the endings sometimes makes the drama hit harder. Same fact, opposite verdicts. Read them side by side and you get the honest picture of this movie.
Be Heumann: the protest before ramps and curb cuts
Vail Daily’s half-week review grades Being Heumann, now streaming on Apple TV, two and a half stars out of four, and outlines the true story underneath: a San Francisco protest demanding the city actually enforce Section 504, the federal rule guaranteeing disabled people equal access — five years after it passed and still ignored.
Even stars get starstruck! Mckenna Grace has a surreal moment meeting Elizabeth Banks at the “The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping” premiere.#MckennaGrace #ElizabethBanks #HungerGames pic.twitter.com/ECxcNWmHgd
The review sketches a world before ramps and curb cuts, when wheelchair users were denied access to schools and sidewalks. Ruth Madeley plays firebrand advocate Judy Heumann, with the review noting the script keeps some fun in the fight for justice and Madeley’s chemistry with Madeline Delp’s Kitty Cone bringing spark the script alone doesn’t supply.
Dylan O’Brien’s Evan White and Mark Ruffalo’s Joseph Califano come off flatter than the leads. Still, it’s recommended as a satisfying crowd-pleaser with something vital to say — and with fresh relevance, in the reviewer’s words, today.
Three stars’ worth of Haymitch
Back in Panem: the deep bench is the one structural complaint Vail Daily raises — a cast too big and too talented for all of them to have enough to do, with Whitney Peak and Maya Hawke singled out as great in the moments they get.
Ralph Fiennes plays a President Snow described by Vulture as rendered with “catatonic sobriety,” a long walk from Donald Sutherland’s fanged glee. Elle Fanning inherits Elizabeth Banks’ Effie Trinket; Kelvin Harrison Jr. steps into Jeffrey Wright’s Beetee.
Culkin, born in 1982 in New York City, has been working since he was a child, making his feature debut in Home Alone (1990) before a breakthrough as the sardonic teenager in Igby Goes Down (2002). After a six-year break from the screen, he returned in Scott Pilgrim vs. the World (2010) and later found a career resurgence on HBO’s Succession.
Vail Daily gives Sunrise on the Reaping three stars
- Sunrise on the Reaping scores three stars out of four from Vail Daily, with Vulture praising it as the franchise’s first proper arena Games in over a decade.
- Joseph Zada’s young Haymitch is the consensus standout; Vulture flags only his accent as a weak spot.
- Being Heumann lands on Apple TV at two and a half stars — a Section 504 protest drama led by Ruth Madeley.
What remains unresolved is whether audiences cry exactly the way Vail Daily predicts, noting that if you’re prepared for tears, though, this is a really good movie, and whether that tears-and-box-office equation holds past opening weekend.