In a blistering column for NBC Sports, Mike Florio argues that Nicolas Cage fundamentally misunderstands John Madden in the new film Madden, streaming now on Prime Video, and that the performance misses the coach’s essence entirely.
Florio, who met Madden once and watched him for decades, writes that the movie is “bad. It’s very bad,” and that Cage’s portrayal reflects none of the “true nature, spirit, and demeanor” of the broadcasting giant. The critique lands as the David O. Russell–directed biopic debuts to mixed reactions, with much of the football world rejecting the casting choice before the opening credits roll.
Cage, speaking to Kirsten Chuba of The Hollywood Reporter, defended his approach by admitting Madden “was not on my radar” growing up. The actor, raised on Orson Welles, Fellini, and Bruce Lee, said he took the role precisely because it was a transformation.
“I’m not an impressionist, I’m not Frank Caliendo,” Cage told the trade. “I lean more towards being a surrealist… I’m trying to give you an evocation, more or less, or an interpretation.”
Florio counters that the result wasn’t “within reason. It was without reason.” The columnist argues that Madden — a towering, booming presence in living rooms for three decades — demands fidelity, not surrealism.
The Bottom Line
- NBC Sports columnist Mike Florio calls the film “very bad” and says Cage misses Madden’s spirit entirely.
- Cage admits he didn’t know Madden and aimed for a “surrealist interpretation” rather than an impression.
- The biopic, directed by David O. Russell, is streaming on Prime Video with Christian Bale as Al Davis.
Surrealism vs. Imitation: The Actor’s Defense
Cage’s comments to The Hollywood Reporter reveal a deliberate artistic choice. He describes his process as filtering Madden’s cadence and appearance “through the cadence and the appearance, within reason, of John Madden” using his “imagination and psyche.”
He also rejected using artificial intelligence to recreate the coach’s voice or face. “I’m not going to let AI touch my voice or my appearance,” Cage said. “I try to give you something which is an interpretation.”

The gap between “evocation” and “recognition” is where the film appears to stumble.
The Russell-Bale-Cage Triangle
The Hollywood Reporter adds crucial context: Russell originally wanted Cage for Al Davis, the Raiders owner played by Christian Bale. Cage turned that down. When Russell circled back with Madden, Cage accepted the challenge. “I’m someone that likes to stay out of my comfort zone and take a risk,” he explained.
This marks Russell’s fourth collaboration with Bale, following The Fighter, American Hustle, and Amsterdam. “I’ve admired Nic for many, many years, going all the way back to Rumble Fish,” Bale told the trade. “He’s not only a fascinating actor but a very interesting man himself. He’s lived a hell of a life, just like Al Davis, just like John Madden, just like David O. Russell.”
The film also features Kathryn Hahn, Sienna Miller, John Mulaney, and Shane Gillis in supporting roles. But the Madden-Davis dynamic — the friendship that built a dynasty and a video game empire — sits at the narrative core.

Streaming Strategy and the Biopic Boom
Madden arrives on Prime Video amid a crowded field of sports IP adaptations. Amazon has bet heavily on live sports — Thursday Night Football — and adjacent storytelling.
Madden’s story is broader: coach, broadcaster, video game namesake.
The Frank Caliendo Problem
Cage name-checked Frank Caliendo unprompted. Caliendo’s Madden impression — the drawl, the telestrator scribbles, the turret enthusiasm — defined the coach for a generation of comedy viewers. It is the baseline. To deviate from it is to invite comparison.

“I’m not Frank Caliendo” is a fair artistic stance. But Florio’s rebuttal cuts to the commercial reality: “The problem was it wasn’t even ‘within reason.’ It was without reason.” When the audience knows the subject better than the actor, surrealism reads as ignorance. Cage’s admission that he “wasn’t interested in team sports whatsoever” becomes a liability, not a badge of purity.
Legacy, Lips, and the Asses They’re Applied To
Florio saves his sharpest line for the industry enablers: “Anyone who says it’s good has no taste and/or an agenda that involves the strategic application of lips to asses.” It’s a reminder that biopics backed by powerful estates, leagues, and studios often face pressure to sanitize. The Madden family and the NFL are producers here.
Florio writes that Madden himself would be livid. “That’s not me,” Florio imagines him saying. “Not even close.” Or perhaps: “This whole thing is antithetical to my identity.”
Mike Florio, born June 8, 1965, in Bellaire, Ohio, and raised in Wheeling, West Virginia, created the website Profootballtalk.com in 2001 while practicing labor law in Clarksburg.
The site became an NBC Sports affiliate in 2009, with Florio retaining ownership through a revenue-sharing deal, and he now hosts the daily NFL talk show PFT Live on Peacock and contributes to Football Night in America. He is the author of Playmakers: How the NFL Really Works (And Doesn’t), released in March 2022.
That line — the film’s own dialogue, repurposed as epitaph — may be the truest thing in the whole production.