NPR: Strong Leads Can’t Save ‘Elsinore’ and ‘I Play Rocky

The cab driver hums the Chariots of Fire theme, and that’s the whole problem in one image.

Two biographical dramas arrive this week — Elsinore, in theaters Friday, November 20, and I Play Rocky — and both star performances are award-caliber while the films around them, critics say, don’t go the distance.

NPR’s review, published Tuesday, makes the case that both movies are built around the Oscars themselves: one about an actor playing Hamlet while dying of AIDS, the other about Sylvester Stallone writing Rocky in three and a half days and refusing to let United Artists make it without him. Both, NPR argues, can’t land their punches despite their leads.

That matters now because awards season is here, the campaigns are running, and the gap between performance and picture will shape the Best Actor race. Andrew Scott’s work in Elsinore has already drawn talk — per The Times’ Kevin Maher, writing after the London Film Festival screening in early October, Scott “has all but secured the Best Actor trophy.”

The catch: if Scott wins at the 2027 Oscars, PinkNews notes he would be the first out gay actor to take Best Actor. Ian McKellen and Colman Domingo were nominated; none have won. Scott, who came out publicly in a 2013 interview, told WSJ. Magazine, “I don’t feel like I have to say anything about that, because the statistic speaks for itself.”

Elsinore Opens in US Theaters Friday

  • Elsinore opens in US theaters Friday, November 20; UK release follows on January 29, 2027.
  • Andrew Scott plays Ian Charleson, the Chariots of Fire star who died January 6, 1990, at 40, of AIDS-related causes.
  • NPR finds both leads better than their films; IGN, Yahoo and Original Cin agree Scott soars while the movie around him frustrates.

A Prince of Denmark Running Out of Time

Elsinore, directed by Australian filmmaker Simon Stone from a Stephen Beresford screenplay, is set in London in 1989. Scott’s Ian Charleson can’t shake the fame of Chariots of Fire — the Best Picture winner whose Vangelis theme follows him into cabs — yet the roles have dried up into Italian horror thrillers, as Yahoo’s review details.

Vf screening room la elsinore hunterabramsstudiosllc
Photo: Vanity Fair

Then fate intervenes. Daniel Day-Lewis drops out of Hamlet at the National Theatre, and director Richard Eyre — played by Johnny Flynn, per Original Cin — hires Charleson. The catch: Charleson is HIV-positive, diagnosed in 1986, closeted, and hiding it from everyone but his closest circle. He tells Eyre himself. When HIV turns to full-blown AIDS mid-rehearsal, he still won’t quit.

Olivia Colman plays Dr. Margaret Johnson, a trailblazing AIDS researcher who wants him off the stage. David Dawson’s Derek Jarman is the only one who truly pushes back, criticizing Charleson for staying closeted. NPR calls Scott’s performance “moving, if more conspicuously effortful” — a man declaiming Shakespeare’s greatest play while slowly succumbing to terminal illness.

Where the Film Fumbles Its Own Story

The consensus among critics is strikingly uniform. NPR says the film “often plays like a feature-length trailer for itself,” stuffed with montages that mash Ian’s art and illness together until both lose meaning. IGN’s review is blunter: “For a movie about a man dying of AIDS, Elsinore is far too blandly amiable.”

NPR: Strong Leads Can't Save 'Elsinore' and 'I Play Rocky
Photo: Yahoo

IGN saves its sharpest cut for the ending — the movie spends its runtime insisting Charleson’s final Hamlet is momentous, then denies us five uninterrupted minutes of it. “I simply sat there confused as the credits rolled,” the reviewer writes. Original Cin, alone among the pack, is warmer, calling the film “grounded and on a human scale” and “not a funeral march.”

One scene earns near-universal praise: Charleson’s rebuke to Jarman, that he owes his life choices to no one and considers himself an actor more than an AIDS patient. IGN calls it one of the film’s best and one of the only moments where Beresford’s script treats its subject as more than a summary.

Sly’s Three-and-a-Half Days, Glossed Over

I Play Rocky, directed by Peter Farrelly from Peter Gamble’s script, is the mirror image: a crowd-pleaser about a legendary arrival rather than a final bow. Anthony Ippolito plays young Stallone as a broke New York nobody — nearly evicted, adopting a stray dog, doing a softcore picture to pay bills, enduring an almost unrecognizable Matt Dillon as his discouraging father. AnnaSophia Robb plays his wife Sasha.

But the math tells a different story about the script’s priorities. Stallone famously wrote Rocky in three and a half days, inspired by the 1975 Muhammad Ali–Chuck Wepner fight — and NPR reports the film glosses over that creative process entirely.

What it does dramatize well is the standoff: Sly refusing to hand over his script unless he stars. Tracy Letts is hilarious as the United Artists executive pushing for Robert Redford or Burt Reynolds.

Andrew scott wsj magazine
Photo: PinkNews

History, of course, proved that executive wrong. Rocky became the top-grossing film of 1976 and won Best Picture. NPR’s verdict: it’s “an underdog story in which the underdog’s triumph feels preordained,” a by-the-numbers movie where the numbers — those museum steps — are admittedly irresistible.

Why the Awards Math Still Favors Scott

The biopic-as-Oscar-vehicle is now an annual tradition — Timothée Chalamet as Bob Dylan was the recent model, and Jessie Buckley won last year for playing Shakespeare’s wife in Hamnet. What makes Elsinore unusual is that the Oscars factor into the story itself, both films dramatizing the machinery of acclaim.

The industry stakes are real. Focus Features is backing Elsinore; Amazon MGM has I Play Rocky. Beresford, who has known Scott for 25 years, told Vanity Fair at the outlet’s Screening Room at LACMA on November 13 that the idea came from a producer: “Well, why didn’t I have that idea myself five years ago?”

The story of Charleson’s Hamlet, he said, “is legendary in the British theater. So many people said it was the greatest Hamlet they’d ever seen.”

Anthony Ippolito stars as Sylvester Stallone in I Play Rocky
Photo: WWNO

Beresford also told Vanity Fair the details of the story “were so incredible, and so moving” once he began researching. Billie Piper, who plays casting agent Patsy Pollock, said she researched the real figures and “cherry-picked things from people I’d known in the beginning of my career,” adding that “a lot of her jokes are coming from a place of despair.”

Two Performers, One Familiar Gap

The pattern across reviews is the same for both films: a lead doing career-best work inside a movie that won’t take risks. Scott, NPR notes, never got the attention he deserved for the delicate, haunting All of Us Strangers in 2023.

Ippolito is, per NPR, “such a dead ringer for young Stallone that you can’t help but believe in him, even when the movie around him doesn’t go anywhere near the distance.”

Scott, now 50, has been building toward this for years — Ripley, Blue Moon, Wake Up Dead Man, and of course Fleabag’s Hot Priest, as Yahoo catalogues. The Guardian’s Benjamin Lee called him “astonishing,” watching him “resiliently try to not cave in to what his body is telling him.”

Charleson himself asked that the cause of his death be made public to raise awareness — a final act of honesty the film, by all accounts, honors even when its construction falters. Elsinore reaches UK cinemas on January 29, 2027, and the campaign that follows will decide whether the performance outruns the picture.

Photo of author

Entertainment Desk

Entertainment Desk at Archyde.

Star Brose Wins Cheung Sha Handicap at Happy Valley; Stewards Quiz Teetan on Tactics

Bepirovirsen Functional Cure Hindered by Quantitative HBsAg Testing Gap