A couple whose son died five days after his birth in February 2022 have settled their High Court action against the HSE and the National Maternity Hospital in Dublin — and, the court was told, the policy changes they fought for are already taking effect.
Niamh Gray and James Kane, from Lusk in Co Dublin, sued over the death of their son Ben, who was delivered at the Holles Street hospital after an attempted home birth and died on February 12th, 2022.
At the High Court on Thursday, Mr Justice Paul Coffey commended the couple for their efforts to see the recommendations of a systems analysis review carried out after Ben’s death implemented, paying tribute to what he called their “selflessness” in trying to ensure the safety of other births.
Speaking outside the Four Courts after the settlement, Gray said the family’s loss remained constant. “He is missing from every memory we make. Our grief does not fade; we are just learning to carry it. This is a pain no parent should ever know,” she said.
The settlement closes a legal action but not the couple’s campaign. Both the HSE and the hospital apologised in letters read to the court, and the court was told that recommendations from the review that followed Ben’s death have been implemented — including changes to how home births are handled when a transfer to hospital becomes necessary.
What the court heard about the timeline
Gray’s waters broke at 8am on February 6th, 2022. According to the court proceedings, community midwives from the HSE’s Home Birth Service did not attend the family’s home until more than 12 hours later, and the two midwives involved should have attended much earlier.

Senior counsel Bruce Antoniotti, instructed by solicitor Rachael Liston, told the court that labour was failing to progress and that had the midwives attended when they should have, difficulties with Gray’s labour would have been identified sooner.
She could have been transferred to hospital earlier and Ben would have been delivered in a healthy manner, he said. There was no concern about the appropriateness of a home birth itself, counsel added.
When it emerged in the early hours that the baby could not be delivered at home, Gray was transferred to the National Maternity Hospital, Holles Street. The court was told Ben was not delivered as soon as he could have been even after Gray arrived there in the early hours of February 7th, 2022.
It was claimed in the proceedings that the delivery and its immediate aftermath were profoundly shocking for both parents. Gray was in severe distress and pain during the latter stage of her labour, and when Ben was born he was limp and required resuscitation. He was diagnosed with hypoxic-ischaemic encephalopathy, placed on palliative care on February 11th, and died the next day.
Apologies read into the court record
In a letter read to the court, the HSE apologised “for any aspect of care that could have contributed to a different outcome for baby Ben” and said it accepted the recommendations made after the systems analysis review.
The National Maternity Hospital expressed its “sincere and deepest sympathies” in its own letter, accepted the review’s findings, and offered the same apology. It added: “We are also truly sorry that our bereavement care after Ben’s death did not meet your needs and for the added distress this has caused.”
Why the parents kept fighting
Gray and Kane said their main concerns had been early checks for a woman in labour, better communication about labour itself, and better communication between midwives and hospitals when a transfer is necessary. The couple said home births are now more integrated into national maternity services as a result of the changes that followed Ben’s death.
“Knowing that policy change has already taken place due to Ben’s death was very important to us. We hope that these changes will ensure that no other family experiences what we have, and no other precious baby loses their life.”
Gray said that for any parent going through a case like this, all they want is change and to be heard when things go wrong. She said she and Kane felt they had the strength to pursue the case, and that having an acknowledgement of breaches of care read into court was important to them as Ben’s parents.
“Our beautiful little boy Ben should be enjoying his second year in pre-school, jumping in puddles and making friends,” Gray said. “Although Ben’s life was short, it was powerful, and we hope he leaves a legacy which will help protect all the babies who will come after him.”
A father’s words about his son’s legacy
Kane said it was very important for Ben’s legacy that they fought for change. “Nothing was ever going to bring Ben back, but if his little life can maybe save a few parents and families going through such a travesty, that is the little mark he has made on this world,” he said.
The National Maternity Hospital, popularly known as Holles Street, was established through charitable donations in 1894 and received a royal charter in 1903. In the 1930s it became the first hospital in Ireland to benefit from the Irish Hospitals’ Sweepstake, which funded an extensive redevelopment of its buildings.
In 1998 it set up the Domino and home birth scheme through its team of community midwives, allowing women to give birth at home under the hospital’s care — the same service that was involved in Ben’s delivery. A foundation charity raising funds for the hospital, with a special emphasis on its neonatal intensive care unit, was established in 2012.
The family lost a son, a brother, a grandson, a nephew and a cousin, Gray said, and Ben is missed every day. He should have been starting school next September, getting excited about Santa, and playing with his two sisters and brother, she said — things he never got the chance to do.