Parole Board Denies Susan Smith Release Again

The parole board voted unanimously Thursday to keep Susan Smith in prison, 32 years after she drowned her two sons in a South Carolina lake.

Smith, 55, needed two-thirds support from the seven-member board to win release.

Thursday’s hearing before the state Department of Probation, Parole and Pardon Services was her second parole bid. The board also rejected her unanimously in 2024, when she first became eligible after serving 30 years of her life sentence. Smith appeared by video call from Leath Correctional Institution in Greenwood.

She was convicted of two counts of murder in July 1995 for the 1994 drownings of 3-year-old Michael and 14-month-old Alex. She left them strapped in their car seats as she let her Mazda roll into John D. Long Lake. The jury chose life imprisonment over the death penalty. The law at the time let her ask for parole after 30 years, then every two years after each refusal.

Father Testifies Against Release

David Smith, the boys’ father, traveled to Columbia with the original prosecutors to argue against her release. He wore pinned over his heart the same photo of Michael and Alex that circled the world in 1994, when the case was still a search for a fictional carjacker.

Susan Smith addresses parole board 32 years after killing her two sons — FOX Carolina News

“She took away one of the greatest gifts God gives us – life. She did that deliberately. It wasn’t an accident, it wasn’t a mistake. She did it deliberately,” he told the board in testimony, according to AP.

He had told CNN ahead of the hearing that 32 years had changed nothing for him. “They didn’t do anything wrong,” he said. “32 years hasn’t changed the heartache.” He also said he had believed his then-wife’s story until he learned on live television that she had killed the children.

Susan Smith Denied Parole as Sons’ Father Pleads To Keep Her Behind Bars - Newsweek
Photo: Newsweek

CNN reported that Smith, 56, wants his ex-wife to stay imprisoned for life. “If I have a choice, I’d want her to stay in prison until she dies,” he said.

The board’s decision matched the weight of public opposition. According to Newsweek, it had received 10,845 statements from concerned citizens against her parole.

Smith Pleads for Mercy

Smith, who sought release a second time, told the board she felt deep remorse. “They were innocent children. They did not deserve to die,” she said.

Susan Smith faces second parole hearing 32 years after killing sons — Fox News

She addressed her ex-husband directly, asking for understanding of how much time has passed.

“I know that David didn’t get to see Michael and Alex grow up. You didn’t get to see him ride a bike or go to school. And I’m really, really sorry for that, and I would go back and change all of that if I could, I would, OK? I’m not the same person I was 32 years ago,” Smith told the board, AP reported.

The odds were steep. The board grants parole in only about 4% of cases before it, most of them non-violent, according to the agency’s statistics.

Parole Board Denies Susan Smith Release Again
Photo: KATU

Two Theories of Why

Prosecutors have long argued that Smith killed her sons because she believed they were the reason the wealthy son of her employer’s owner, Tom Findlay, broke off their affair. Her defense at trial instead blamed her mental health, saying she planned to drive into the lake with the boys but changed her mind.

Psychologist Jessie Hill testified Thursday that Smith’s mental illness has been greatly subdued by medication, hormonal changes from menopause, and the deaths of her mother and stepfather. The stepfather admitted in court that he had sexually abused her from before she was a teenager, AP reported.

(LIVE) Parole hearing for notorious child killer Susan Smith — WLOS News 13

Outside the hearing, a former inmate offered a blunter verdict on Smith. Tracey Thompson, who told Fox News she was intimately involved with Smith in prison, said Smith belongs behind bars permanently.

“You’d have to be a sociopath to do what she did!” Thompson told the outlet. She also said Smith spoke of regret constantly behind bars: “She always missed them. She regretted what she did.”

“She did something horrible. She belongs in jail for the rest of her life,” Thompson said.

Parole Board Denies Susan Smith Release Again
Photo: WACH.com

Case Gripped Nation in 1994

On Oct. 25, 1994, Smith, then 23, told police a Black man had carjacked her near Union and driven off with her sons, WLOS reported. The claim set off a nine-day international search, during which she made tearful televised pleas. It cast suspicion on Black residents of the town, the AP noted, playing into a racist trope that fueled 1990s crime anxieties.

She confessed on Nov. 3, 1994. Investigators later reconstructed the sinking: it took six minutes for her Mazda to dip below the surface, with cameras inside showing water pouring in through the vents. The boys’ bodies were found dangling upside-down in their car seats, one small hand pressed against a window.

SC v. Susan Smith – Parole Hearing — COURT TV

Her three decades in prison have not been quiet, either. She has faced repeated disciplinary charges. Months before the 2024 hearing, the South Carolina Department of Corrections charged her with communicating with a witness over phone calls with a documentary filmmaker, CNN reported.

Here is how the case has unfolded:

Leath Correctional Institution, where Smith appeared by video call, opened in September 1991 on a 39-acre site in unincorporated Greenwood County near Greenwood. The women’s prison has a capacity of 968 and, as of 2016, held 562 prisoners. Its Braille Production Center, where inmates create materials for schoolchildren, began operating in 2002.

  • Oct. 25, 1994 — Smith reports that her sons were taken in a carjacking; a nine-day nationwide search follows.
  • Nov. 3, 1994 — She confesses to letting the car roll into John D. Long Lake with the boys inside.
  • July 1995 — A jury convicts her of two counts of murder and sentences her to life instead of the death penalty.
  • Nov. 20, 2024 — The board unanimously denies her first parole request.
  • Nov. 19, 2026 — The board unanimously denies parole again, 32 years after the drownings.

Under the law that governs her sentence, Smith can ask again in two years. David Smith, who pledged at the first hearing to oppose her release for as long as he can, said he will be there again. “I know in my heart that granting her parole would be a huge injustice to Michael and Alex,” he told the board, according to the Daily Mail.

Photo of author

Entertainment Desk

Entertainment Desk at Archyde.

UMass Tennis Signs Estonian, Croatian Players for 2027-28 Season