Pat Cummins’ agent has spent the past 24 hours repeating the Australia captain’s account of the Cape Town ball-tampering affair, with the captaincy itself now hanging on a Perth crowd.
Cummins is due to lead Australia in the first Test against New Zealand in Perth on December 9. Cricket Australia has backed him, and BBC Sport reports no obvious suggestion he has considered resigning or will be sacked.
Jonathan Agnew, the BBC cricket correspondent, frames the stakes bluntly: this is one of the biggest stories in the history of Australian sport, reignited by Cameron Bancroft’s 4,000-word testimony in a Western Australian newspaper.
The press, he writes, will bang away until they get the truth. Agnew also delivers the tactical verdict that keeps the story alive: as a former bowler, he never believed the bowling attack could have been unaware of what happened in Cape Town in 2018.
Fantasy & Market Impact
- Captaincy futures carry unresolved risk. Cummins remains the scheduled leader for the Perth Test on December 9, and any market or fantasy roster built around him as Australia’s captain stays frozen until his status is settled.
- The bowling core is untouched in every scenario. Even under Agnew’s resignation scenario, Cummins could continue in the ranks, leaving Mitchell Starc, Josh Hazlewood and Nathan Lyon — the engine of Australia’s Test attack — fully intact for selection purposes.
- Ashes futures face the same doubt. Agnew cannot currently imagine Cummins tossing the coin at Trent Bridge on June 18 next summer, so any longer-dated pricing on Australia’s Ashes captaincy rests on a decision that has not been made.
Why the Bowlers Had to Know
Here is the structural argument Yahoo Sports carries in Agnew’s full column: the ball belongs to the bowlers. It is the bowling attack’s weapon.
“It has never seemed remotely plausible to me, as a former bowler, that the bowlers didn’t know what was happening in Cape Town in 2018,” writes Jonathan Agnew, BBC cricket correspondent.
His logic runs both ways. Just as a bowler would not sand an edge or change the grip on a batter’s bat, no batter would work on the ball without a bowler’s knowledge.
Ball-tampering, he writes, has existed as long as cricket has — once a matter of sweets used to put a sheen on one side — and reverse swing, which demands a roughed-up and dried ball, transformed the practice.
Why did the reckoning take so long? Players, Agnew argues, only go public once retired or near the end of their international careers. And on the original sanctions he is unsparing: Smith was captain and should have been in control, Warner cooked up the sandpaper idea, Bancroft executed it. If the three took bullets for team-mates, they were bullets they deserved.
Cummins Calls the Claims Nonsense
The current captain has not stayed silent. The Boston Project’s copy of the column carries the caption from Cummins’ media appearance on November 12, where he rejected claims made by Usman Khawaja over the sandpaper scandal.
Australian cricket captain Pat Cummins on sandpaper allegations https://t.co/Kpb9KEgSMl
At his November 12 media appearance, Australia captain Pat Cummins described the claims made by Usman Khawaja over the sandpaper scandal as “100% wrong” and “utter nonsense.”
His agent’s interventions in the past 24 hours continue the same defence. Overnight, pictures also emerged from Australia of Cummins being confronted outside his home, BBC Sport reported.
Agnew’s assessment of the man is two-sided. Cummins is not a typical Australian captain — not abrasive, not in your face — and he is credible when he says he has worked hard to correct his team’s image. But he missed a trick to prove Australia are no longer a win-at-all-costs outfit with the Jonny Bairstow stumping at Lord’s during the 2023 Ashes.
Then there is the vow that complicates everything. Cummins has said he never wants to talk about sandpaper again — which Agnew calls ludicrous given what an Ashes tour would bring: media scrutiny and constant baiting from the crowds.

Perth Awaits on December 9
The litmus test, Agnew writes, is the public reaction. Perth is Bancroft’s home city, sitting in the state of the newspaper that first published his 4,000-word testimony. If Cummins is still captain by then, the crowd’s response to him will be very interesting.
| Date | Development |
|---|---|
| 2018 | Ball-tampering with sandpaper against South Africa in Cape Town; Bancroft executed the plan Warner devised, with Smith as captain |
| 2023 | Bairstow stumping at Lord’s during the Ashes |
| Past 24 hours | Agent repeats Cummins’ account; pictures emerge of him confronted outside his home |
The build-up itself is the problem. In Agnew’s view, it is hard to imagine the occasion turning into anything but a circus, with sandpaper questions and disputes over who knew what and who said what to whom taking centre stage.
A Resignation Without Admitting Guilt
Agnew identifies one clean exit. One route open to Cummins would be to step down while accepting no blame, framing the departure around the idea that the speculation has become a distraction for the team and the pressure is taking a toll on his family life.
He could then continue in the ranks, just as Warner and Smith did — a move that would also take heat off Starc, Hazlewood and Lyon.
Either way, the questions outlast the man. Reflecting on 2018, Agnew writes, the Australia camp carried a sense that they were fireproof — that they could get away with anything. Credit, according to Bancroft, goes to media manager Kate Hutchison, who made a stand about what was going on and knew what would happen if the Australians got caught.
Then there are the coaches who were supposed to guide and protect young men: Darren Lehmann, now in his position at Northamptonshire, and David Saker, who has recently been working with England. Cricket Australia has seemed so reluctant to get involved that the idea of letting individuals “tell their truth” behind closed doors is, in Agnew’s judgment, dead in the water.
Cricket Australia traces its origins to the Australian Board of Control for International Cricket, formed in 1905 and first convened at Wesley College in Melbourne on 6 May that year. The company was incorporated in its present form in 1982, and it now operates the men’s, women’s and under-19 national teams alongside Indigenous and disability sides.
It was the Australian board that took control of tours away from the players themselves — a power struggle that led an earlier council to establish the Sheffield Shield in 1892, the first-class competition still contested between the states today.
BBC cricket correspondent Jonathan Agnew concludes by stating that telling the truth is the only option, as nothing else is good enough.