The Pennsylvania State Board of Education voted 9-5 Thursday to reject a department proposal that would have lowered the score needed for an “advanced” rating on statewide exams, leaving nearly 900,000 students and their schools waiting longer for results that were already months overdue.
The decision blocks a plan to recalibrate cut scores for the Pennsylvania System of School Assessment and Keystone Exams for the first time since 2015, a move the Department of Education argued was necessary to align with the state’s shift to fully online testing.
Instead, the department must now re-score the spring 2026 exams under the old thresholds, a process Deputy Secretary Amy Lena acknowledged “will take a little bit of time,” Altoona Mirror reported.
“I’m not convinced that 2026, the year when nearly half the students took the test online for the first time and there were tech issues in its administration … is the right year to serve as our baseline going forward,” said state Sen. Lindsey Williams, the minority chair of the Senate Education Committee, who voted against the proposal.
Williams told Chalkbeat Philadelphia that communication breakdowns at multiple points left board members and the public insufficient time to weigh the implications.
The online transition that triggered the review
Spring 2026 marked the first year Pennsylvania required all districts to administer the PSSA and Keystone exams online. The transition brought widespread technical glitches, according to board members and district officials. The Department of Education said the shift created an opportunity to re-evaluate whether the existing scoring thresholds—last set when the exams were paper-based—still accurately reflected student mastery.

A panel of 90 educators convened through a process called Standards Validation recommended the new cut scores. Brian Campbell, director of the Bureau of Curriculum, Assessment and Instruction, told the board the updated descriptors would give teachers a direct link to develop lesson plans around performance-level data.
The proposed changes would not have altered the proficiency cutoff, which remains at a scaled score of 1,000, but would have lowered the bar for the “advanced” designation, potentially placing more students in the top category, WJAC-TV reported.
Philadelphia school selection stalled
The delay hits hardest in Philadelphia, where the school district has twice postponed its school-selection window for criteria-based magnet schools while waiting for official PSSA results. Students must meet minimum score thresholds to qualify for admission. The application deadline was most recently pushed to Dec. 16, The Philadelphia Inquirer reported.
“The whole purpose of having these assessments is to inform instruction for the coming year, and right now we’re almost halfway through the current year,” said board Vice Chair Carol Aichele, who voted for the proposal.

Critics see a pattern of lowered expectations
Opponents of the proposal argued that lowering the advanced threshold—even without touching the proficiency line—would obscure longitudinal data and make it harder to gauge actual academic improvement. Mark Gleason, managing partner of The Drexel Fund, told the board the change mirrored a national trend of lowering K-12 standards while student performance on national and international exams declines.
“This is the national trend,” Gleason said. Rachel Langan, policy analyst for the Commonwealth Foundation, said Pennsylvanians should be “highly suspect” of changes that muddy achievement data used to determine state funding allocations.
The vote revealed a rare split among the four legislative members who serve on the board by virtue of their committee chairs. Williams and Senate Education Committee Chair David Argall voted no. House Education Committee Chair Peter Schweyer was the lone legislator to vote yes, saying an update was overdue despite the flawed timing.

“We’ve gone way too long for addressing these cut scores in any kind of systematic or thoughtful manner,” Schweyer told Chalkbeat Philadelphia. Board member Sandra Dungee Glenn echoed that the educator panel’s work was sound but agreed the implementation should wait until next year.
Department determining next steps for 2026 results
The Department of Education said it respects the board’s decision and is determining how best to support students moving forward. No new timeline has been provided for releasing the 2026 results to districts and families. Scores are typically available in August; as of late November, students are still waiting.
“We will just have to go back, we’ll have to make sure that we run them under the old scoring system,” Lena said. “That will take a little bit of time.”
Zaida Easton, a student who testified during the public comment period, captured the frustration many families feel. “By cutting test scores, I think that’s missing the point,” Easton told WJAC-TV. “We want them to keep pushing and striving for more.”