Phylicia Rashad is commanding the screen in season four of HBO’s The Gilded Age, portraying the rigid Newport matriarch Elizabeth Kirkland as she faces a seismic shift in her family’s traditionalist values.
As her son prepares to marry Peggy Scott, Rashad’s character must reconcile her deep-seated prejudices with her devotion.
The Kirkland Family Dynamic
- Rashad’s character, Elizabeth Kirkland, reluctantly accepts Peggy Scott into the family to avoid losing her son, Dr. Kirkland.
- The performance highlights the tension between 19th-century societal decorum and the changing personal agency of the younger generation.
- The season four narrative explores the historical reality of colorism and the internal struggle of characters clinging to Eurocentric traditions.
The conflict reaches a breaking point on the eve of the wedding. For two seasons, Mrs. Kirkland has been the architect of opposition against Peggy, viewing her career as a novelist and her family history as incompatible with her own status.
When Peggy presents an ultimatum—attend the wedding or remain “on the outside”—Rashad delivers a performance that transcends mere villainy. She portrays a woman whose entire sense of self-worth is tethered to a rigid, often exclusionary, social framework.
“I grew up in Houston, Texas. Colorism still exists today. I thought, What a wonderful opportunity to explore this mindset, to revel in its ridiculousness, and expose that to people,” Rashad said. She says that for Mrs. Kirkland, the refusal to accept the Scott family traditions—such as jumping the broom—is not just personal preference, but an attempt to “protect the bloodline.”
The Theatrical Roots of the Cast
The intensity of the performances on The Gilded Age is no accident. Rashad has described the program as unique in that the entire cast was theater royalty, with friends of hers among them, including Audra McDonald and John Douglas Thompson. Rashad, who earned her first of two Tony Awards for A Raisin in the Sun in 2004, fits that mold herself.
| Production Element | Impact on Performance |
|---|---|
| Theater Pedigree | Ensures complex, nuanced character exploration |
| Historical Costuming | Forces physical posture and emotional restraint |
| Social Commentary | Exposes the “ridiculousness” of 19th-century colorism |
Kirkland Family Dynamics Expand the Show's Reach
When confronted with the history of her own descendants, Mrs. Kirkland remains entrenched, illustrating the difficulty of shaking foundations built on misinformation.
The shift in energy during season three and into season four has been palpable. The introduction of the Kirkland family dynamics has expanded the show’s reach, with Rashad noting that friends who hadn’t watched the show before are now watching it, and that one friend following the social media conversation told her, “I’m trying to save Claire Huxtable.”
“Darling, we have fun conversations. One time he said to me, ‘Elizabeth, if you don’t stop it, I’m going to spank you.’ And I looked at him and I said, ‘Do you promise?'” Rashad said of her off-screen rapport with co-star Brian Stokes Mitchell.
As the series moves forward, the question remains whether Elizabeth Kirkland will ever truly evolve. Rashad suggests that the character’s growth will require her to “admit things” and come to understandings that “trouble her waters,” a process that mirrors the broader human struggle to expand awareness. Whether Mrs. Kirkland can ultimately move past the concepts she has lived by for a lifetime remains the central tension of her arc.
What do you think of Elizabeth Kirkland’s “dark night of the soul” as she chooses between her traditions and her son? Sound off in the comments below.