Property Lawyer Warns Off-Plan Buyers of Developer Sunset Clause Traps

Property buyers signing off-the-plan contracts face significant financial exposure from shifting interest rates, changing property valuations, and developer-friendly clauses that can permit contract cancellations.

The risk profile of purchasing real estate before construction finishes was detailed by Sue Foley, property lawyer and owner of Landley Law, during an appearance on The Prosperity Project podcast hosted by Nadine Higgins, the NZ Herald reported.

Assessing Property Risk Exposure

Buyers frequently enter agreements without fully calculating the gap between initial contract signing and eventual settlement day. Foley told Higgins that her firm conducts direct assessments with clients before any paperwork is signed.

“Sometimes when we start working with people … it becomes evident that their risk appetite isn’t sufficient to buy off plan, and we’ll often be quite direct with them about it” said Foley.

Market conditions shift unpredictably during construction periods. Debt servicing costs alter immediately when monetary policy adjustments change interest rates.

Simultaneously, property value declines can destroy a buyer’s loan-to-value ratio calculations required by commercial lenders. However, Foley said that identical macro forces benefit purchasers if local real estate values climb upward prior to title issuance.

Contractual Risk Factor Market Impact Buyer Exposure Level
Interest Rate Shifts Modifies debt servicing costs High
Valuation Fluctuations Alters loan-to-value ratios High
Sunset Clauses Permits cancellation for delayed titles Severe
Price Escalation Clauses Increases agreed purchase price Moderate

Avoiding Contractual Traps

Legal agreements often include provisions designed to protect developers from indefinite construction delays. Sunset clauses typically allow contract terminations if a project misses a specified completion deadline.

During the property market boom associated with the Covid-era, certain developers exploited these rules. Foley explained that some entities deliberately delayed obtaining titles and code compliance certificates.

When market pricing moved higher, developers recognized they could cancel existing agreements and resell properties to alternative buyers for larger sums.

“They might deliberately delay the issue of title and code because the market has moved and they know darn well they could cancel the contract and sell it to another buyer for more money” said Foley.

Foley recommends that sunset clauses should ideally benefit buyers exclusively. When contracts grant developers cancellation rights, buyers should demand written warranties preventing developers from exercising those clauses merely to capture higher resale figures.

Price Escalation and Material Substitution

Additional contractual hazards include price escalation clauses. These provisions permit developers to inflate final purchase prices if building materials and labor expenses rise.

Substitution clauses represent another common hazard. They allow builders to alter specified construction materials and installed appliances without prior owner consent.

Foley emphasizes the necessity of employing specialized legal counsel to review these specific terms before execution. Legal teams frequently negotiate amendments to eliminate unfavorable clauses before deals proceed.

“It’s knowing what clauses to watch out for as a lawyer, and then sometimes you need to go back and negotiate them, to try and get the best outcome for your buyer” said Foley.

Prospective purchasers must accumulate substantial capital reserves prior to settlement. Lower loan amounts reduce overall exposure to monetary policy adjustments and asset price volatility.

“Save as much as possible before settlement, because the less money you borrow, the less you’re affected by change in interest rates and changes in value” said Foley.

Sue Foley has practiced property law in Christchurch for over 25 years as director and solicitor of Landley Law Limited. Before founding the firm, she built her career specialising in property and general practice, focusing on establishing direct client relationships and delivering clear, practical legal advice.

Disclaimer: The information provided in this article is for educational and informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice.

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

Center for Scholars & Storytellers: 5.4% of Adolescents Don’t Game; Bloomscrolling, AI Animal Scams Noted