RTÉ: US Proposes Ukraine Cede Territory for NATO Membership as Envoys Meet in Berlin

The US has asked Ukraine whether it would give up territory for NATO membership, but the trade-off convinces almost nobody: RTÉ’s analysis argues the proposal asks a victim state to surrender land seized by force for security guarantees that may never be ratified, as envoys meet in Berlin today.

Why won’t the US proposal of NATO membership for Ukraine in exchange for withdrawing from Donbas end the Ukraine war?

Because it asks both sides to accept something they have each sworn to reject — RTÉ reported that Washington wants Kyiv to cede roughly 20% of its sovereign territory in exchange for NATO membership, terms Moscow calls unacceptable and Kyiv refuses to treat as surrender. Today, US, Ukrainian and European envoys meet in Berlin to try to square that circle, RTÉ reported.

What happened at Baldonnel?

Last week, Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky met US envoys Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff at Casement Aerodrome, the Irish military airport at Baldonnel. RTÉ noted the venue’s own irony: it is named after Roger Casement, executed in 1916 for seeking Ireland’s freedom from a powerful imperial neighbour. The stopover suited a wartime president travelling between Moscow and Washington.

Kushner told reporters, per RTÉ, that Europe must be "at the table" for peace talks — a shift, since Moscow has publicly doubted any EU role. RTÉ raises the obvious question: why now? It may be good faith, or it may be Washington wanting Europe to share the blame if talks collapse, or to fund reconstruction.

US proposes NATO membership for Donbas withdrawal

“The Americans raised a question: ‘What if Ukraine joins NATO? Would Ukraine withdraw from Donbas?'” he told reporters in remarks released on Saturday, as The Journal reported in details of the proposal. He said it was the first time the trade had been raised.

The detail matters. According to a report by the Kyiv Independent on the security package, Kyiv has sought guarantees modelled on Article 5 “as an absolute minimum,” while Washington offers something “similar to Articles 4 and 5” — no American troops, and bilateral guarantees resembling Israel’s. Zelensky was blunt about what is missing: “But we need specifics, and we don’t have them yet.”

He also set his own limits. Any deal would come “without any recognition of the occupied territories as Russian,” he said, and explicitly rejected neutrality: “If Putin expects Ukraine’s neutrality to be enshrined, that’s not going to happen,” he told reporters, as The Guardian reported his remarks. If concrete guarantees materialised, he would put the question to a referendum.

Why RTÉ calls the trade a false compromise

Russia is the aggressor state, having launched its aggression in 2014 and scaled it up in 2022 at the cost of the lives of over 400,000 of its own people. Under the UN Charter, territory cannot be acquired by force — treating occupied land as a bargaining chip, RTÉ argues, rewards the aggressor before any agreement is signed.

And the prize on offer is shakier than it sounds. NATO membership requires unanimous ratification by every member state’s parliament, a process RTÉ notes could be stalled by domestic politics or Russian interference. Ukraine has been here before: the Budapest Memorandum of 1994 promised security assurances that proved worthless.

RTÉ also points to history’s warnings — the 1938 Munich Agreement that stripped Czechoslovakia of its fortified Sudetenland defences, the 1940 Moscow Peace Treaty that forced Finland to cede a tenth of its territory, and the Dayton Accords that froze Bosnia and Herzegovina into fragile and perennial dysfunction.

RTÉ: US Proposes Ukraine Cede Territory for NATO Membership as Envoys Meet in Berlin
Photo: The Journal

Where the outlets diverge — and where the fighting continues

Newsweek framed the question as a striking departure for President Donald Trump, who told Fox News in August 2025 that Kyiv was “not going to be a part of NATO.” Al Jazeera’s analysis called the offer a surprise given Trump’s sympathy for Moscow’s position, while noting Moscow’s own demands that Ukraine cede sovereignty over Donbas, in addition to parts of Zaporizhia and Kherson provinces that Russia already occupies.

The war meanwhile did not pause for diplomacy. Zelensky said Russia rejected an energy-target ceasefire at talks this week, and was “betting everything” on this winter’s campaign in its war with Ukraine.

He also accused SpaceX of restricting Starshield satellite terminals operating in temporarily Russian-occupied territories of Ukraine to a maximum speed of 161 kp/h for the past five days, hampering Ukraine’s military capabilities — a move he called political rather than technical.

Zelenskyy's talks with Witkoff, Kushner over Russia-Ukraine war wrap in Berlin

What happens in Berlin — and after

Today’s Berlin meeting will test whether European envoys can hold the line. RTÉ reports that European states remain broadly unified behind legal and security red lines, but with major national elections looming in 2027, that cohesion cannot be taken for granted. Russia, meanwhile, is pushing back against any EU seat at the table, aware meaningful European participation would shift the balance of power.

The next date to watch is already fixed: the European Council summit on November 26 and 27, Newsweek reported, where Zelensky has warned Putin could try to turn the talks into a wider bargain over Europe’s security architecture. Zelensky himself put the sequence plainly: “This war must be ended first.”

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

Woman Refuses to Lock Away Cat for Christmas, Family Pressures Her to Host Elsewhere

Semantic Attribute Leakage: Taxonomy, Mechanisms, and Benchmark Critique in Diffusion Models