A woman’s refusal to lock away her cat during Christmas hosting plans has sparked a dramatic debate online, after her 60-year-old father asked her to host the holiday in her small apartment — on the condition that the pet be shut in a room while the family visited.
The woman, who shared the story on Reddit in a post covered by TwistedSifter, said she and her husband were open to hosting but drew the line at confining their cat for the evening.
“My apartment is pretty small, and I’d rather him not be locked away in a room for who knows how long while they are here.”
She said the apartment is as much the cat’s home as hers, and that no guest has a medical reason to keep the animal apart.
“This isn’t only my place, it’s also my cat’s. My husband and I both agree that we shouldn’t have to put him away just because someone has asked. It’s also not like anyone coming over is allergic either. They just don’t like cats.”
When she declined her father’s request, the conversation turned tense. She said her stepmother reacted badly to her refusal.
“When I said I wouldn’t put him away because this is his house too, my stepmother was very demanding and pushy about it. She has also been drinking and slurring her words, which always seems to be the case when I talk to them.”
Now the woman is weighing whether to issue an ultimatum to her family. Christmas is usually held at her sister’s home, she said.
“If I host, he’s not being put away, or you’ll have to find somewhere else to have Christmas.”
She ended her post by asking the internet whether she was in the wrong, writing: “So, AITA for not wanting to put away my cat while my family is here?”
Commenters largely sided with her, with responses arguing that her family “shouldn’t have asked her to host if they weren’t satisfied with the state of her living arrangements” and that some people “have absolute control over other people’s lives,” according to the report.
A write-up on Cheezburger framed the dispute as a question of hosting rules: if it’s your house, do you get to make the rules, or should a host bend to the needs of guests?
Not every observer took her side. Some argued that two hours in a bedroom with a bed, a bowl and a toy would hardly be a punishment, and that her stubbornness matched her family’s pushiness. It is starting to look like the family will need to have Christmas somewhere else this year.