Tuscan punk quartet Scraffs exited X Factor Italy on Thursday night, eliminated during the fourth Live show, Corriere della Sera reported, according to Zazoom.
The Valdarno band — singer-bassist Daniel Jon Stephens, guitarist Leonardo Randazzo (known as Randal The Vandal), guitarist Dario Aveotti and drummer Cristian Basile — had just performed Hole’s “Celebrity Skin” and Green Day’s “American Idiot” to positive feedback from the panel, but the public vote sent them home on the eve of the episode dedicated to original material, according to Corriere della sera. The eliminations of the fourth Live leave a bitter taste for the band, according to Il Messaggero. If the exit of Manu could be predicted after the previous week’s showdown with Lenanie and the difficulties shown during the evening, the same cannot be said for the Tuscan band.
The four boys from Valdarno had just lived one of their best evenings since the start of the Lives, rediscovering that punk soul that had conquered the judges at the Auditions. First “Celebrity Skin” by Hole in the Jukebox round, then “American Idiot” by Green Day in the cover round. Two performances charged with energy, accompanied by appreciation from the table.
Yet it was not enough. The public decided to eliminate the Scraffs, interrupting their path right on the eve of the episode dedicated to original songs. A bitter verdict for four boys who had declared they wanted to build their own artistic identity. “We want to make the Scraffs,” they had answered the judges just hours before.
“We really made a bomb of a performance,” Stephens said. “We worked a lot in the studio and we were happy. It was a performance that satisfied us, also because the response from the public and the judges was positive. We didn’t resent it that much. We were happy. And then I wanted to have a gin and tonic.”
The band, whose name means “scraps” or “wreckage,” entered the live shows under mentor Francesco Gabbani.
The group also criticized judge Paola Iezzi for misunderstanding their Joey Ramone version of “What a Wonderful World” at the first Live.
Despite the early exit, the band is moving forward. “We are working on it, I can anticipate that. We would love very much to publish it on vinyl, but it would be an effort that at the moment we don’t know if we can sustain, we come from a small province and we have no one behind us. They celebrated the exit with a gin and tonic, and already look to the future: “We have foam at the mouth for the next live.”
Mentor Francesco Gabbani, born in 1982, won the Sanremo Music Festival newcomers’ section in 2016 with “Amen” and the main competition in 2017 with “Occidentali’s Karma,” becoming the first artist to win both categories in consecutive years. He represented Italy at the Eurovision Song Contest 2017 in Kyiv, finishing sixth. In 2025, he joined the nineteenth season of X Factor Italy as a mentor.

Reflecting on the Italian underground scene, the members compared it to Orwell’s Animal Farm: “All animals are equal, but some are more equal than others.” They cited a lack of venues — “places are scarce” — and talent scouts who “look at likes on social media instead of following bands live,” while crediting journalist Giuliano Girlando for giving them their first Rome gig at CSOA La Strada. Despite X Factor, or other virtuous realities like the Rock Contest, for emerging artists it is never simple to establish themselves.
What is the most difficult aspect you have encountered so far? “To play. Despite some small realities, like the Wip in Terranova, where we met, venues are scarce. Often the underground world is seen as an ivory tower, where, quoting Orwell's Animal Farm, 'all animals are equal, but some are more equal than others' — the underground world works a bit like that. Are talent scouts lacking?”