A Pretoria restaurant added a 10% service charge to roughly 200 bills a day, and South Africa’s National Consumer Tribunal has ruled that doing so was unlawful.
The tribunal found the restaurant guilty of prohibited conduct under the Consumer Protection Act, BusinessTech reported. It stopped short of the R1 million fine the National Consumer Commission had asked for.
The ruling turns on a distinction most diners never think to make. The restaurant did disclose the charge on its menu, called it discretionary, and said management would remove it on request. That, the tribunal held, was not enough. Customers should not have to challenge an automatically added charge to avoid paying it.
The menu fine print that was not enough
What the menu actually said matters here, because it shows how far the tribunal was willing to read past fine print.
The wording read: “a discretionary charge of 10% will be added to your bill. Please notify management if the service you received is not up to standard. Management will gladly remove it from your bill.” Read one way, that discloses everything. Read the tribunal’s way, it flips the burden onto the diner.
South African law already gives consumers a right to good-quality service. A restaurant that adds the charge first and removes it only when challenged effectively asks diners to trade away that right, or to haggle over a bill they never agreed to in the first place.
Service charges must be voluntary
Consumer rights expert Wendy Knowler, speaking to The Money Show, said complaints about automatic service charges had become increasingly common across the restaurant industry. She explained the legal core of the case in plain terms.
“Section 23 of the Consumer Protection Act says that a supplier cannot make you pay more than the displayed price. And paying for service has always got to be voluntary and not mandatory,” Knowler said.
Restaurant's defence falls short on scale
The restaurant defended itself on several grounds, and the tribunal took some of them seriously. It argued the charge was disclosed, discretionary, and removable. It said all the money went to waiters as tips. And it told the National Consumer Commission that no diner had ever come forward to say a request to remove the charge was refused.
The commission still treated the matter as systemic rather than isolated, precisely because of the scale: about 200 service-charge transactions processed every day. A practice running at that volume, applied to all bills regardless of party size, goes beyond the traditional large-group service fee diners know and generally accept.
Knowler said she understood why restaurants want to charge bigger tables, where one waiter can spend most of an evening serving a single group. Blanket charges applied to everyone were the problem. So was the way diners encounter them.
“A lot of people just are used to looking for the bottom figure and then adding their tip onto that,” she said.
That habit is exactly what makes an automatic charge expensive in practice. A diner scanning for the total never notices a line item quietly baked in, then tips on top of it. The tribunal described a genuinely voluntary gratuity as one a consumer freely elects to pay.
“It is not an amount automatically added to a bill and removed only if a consumer challenges it,” Knowler said.
What the law still allows
The tribunal did not outlaw service charges altogether. It made clear the Consumer Protection Act does not stop restaurants from charging for services.
What the law requires is that establishments spell out what those services involve and display the full price upfront, so customers can decide before ordering whether the deal suits them. A discretionary 10% for services nobody has described or itemised, Knowler said, gives diners no certainty about what they are buying.
Why no R1 million fine
The commission had asked for R1 million. Knowler said several factors worked in the restaurant’s favour instead: it had not acted in bad faith, the money genuinely reached the waiters, and no evidence showed the restaurant profited from the charges. No specific financial loss was presented to the tribunal. The restaurant also cooperated with the investigation and removed the wording from its menu.
So the penalty is a declaration rather than a cheque, but the declaration carries weight. Prohibited conduct findings under the Consumer Protection Act set the boundary for an entire industry, and this one lands on a practice some establishments had quietly adopted: applying a blanket 10% charge to every bill, sometimes without properly telling diners, as Knowler described in BusinessTech’s reporting on the case.
Restaurants must disclose charges before meals
For restaurants, the tribunal’s message is that disclosure must happen before the meal, not on the bill, and a charge must be voluntary in fact rather than removable only in theory. For diners, the ruling confirms something easy to forget the moment the bill lands: a tip added without your say-so is not a tip at all, and you are entitled to have it struck off without argument.
Knowler put the failure case bluntly. Where customers are not clearly informed about a service charge and only discover it when the bill arrives, “then that’s obviously quite sneaky and not in the consumer’s interest,” she said.
What remains open is enforcement. The tribunal declared the conduct prohibited but issued no fine and no costs order, and no follow-up mechanism for other restaurants still running similar policies has been recorded. Whether the industry adjusts on its own, or more cases follow until the R1 million deterrent becomes real, is not something the ruling itself settles.