Long Sleep Linked to 50% Higher Mortality Risk in Adults With Heart Disease, PLOS One Study Reports

Adults with heart disease who sleep nine or more hours a day face roughly a 50% higher risk of death over 15 years than those sleeping seven to eight hours, a study published in PLOS One reports.

The finding, News-Medical reported this week, positions long sleep as a warning marker — not a cause — of hidden vulnerability in cardiac patients.

The study drew on 3,287 US adults with self-reported heart disease from the 2004 National Health Interview Survey, linked to the National Death Index through December 31, 2019, News-Medical reported. Over roughly 15 years of follow-up, 49.4% of participants died — 16.7% from heart-related causes and 32.6% from other causes.

Compared with the 7–8 hour reference group, sleeping nine or more hours carried a hazard ratio of 1.51 for death from all causes, 1.53 for heart-related death, and 1.50 for non-heart-related death — increases of 51%, 53%, and 50% respectively. A hazard ratio, in plain terms, expresses how much more likely one group is to experience an event than another over the same period.

What makes the number striking is its comparison: the authors note the 51% all-cause increase exceeds the roughly 30% reported in a previous general-population meta-analysis, suggesting long sleep carries stronger prognostic weight in people who already have heart disease, News-Medical reported.

Long sleep may signal health issues, not cause death

  • If you have heart disease and consistently sleep nine hours or more, mention it at your next appointment — it may flag an issue worth investigating.
  • Long sleep here appeared to be a marker of poor health, not a cause of death. The study does not show that cutting sleep would lower risk.
  • Short sleep (six hours or less) showed no significant link to death after full statistical adjustment in this population.

Why long sleep may signal frailty, not cause it

The authors suggest prolonged sleep may reflect underlying health vulnerability in a high-risk population — pointing to depression, sleep-disordered breathing, inflammation, frailty, multimorbidity, and medication burden as possible contributors, News-Medical reported. Sleep regulates metabolism, inflammation, autonomic function, and cardiovascular recovery, which is why sleep duration attracts attention as a potentially modifiable, easily assessed lifestyle factor.

Across ten sensitivity analyses — including excluding deaths in the first two years, competing-risk models, and excluding cancer history — all-cause hazard ratios generally ranged from 1.42 to 1.77. A survey-weighted analysis produced a smaller 26% increase. The persistence after removing early deaths reduces, but does not eliminate, concern that pre-existing illness explains the finding.

Restricted cubic spline analysis — a statistical method for detecting curved, rather than straight-line, relationships — showed a significant U-shaped pattern for all-cause and non-heart-related mortality. The lowest predicted risk fell near 6.5 hours for all-cause mortality, and at 6 and 6.8 hours for heart-related and non-heart-related mortality. The authors caution these estimates do not establish an optimal sleep target.

The numbers at a glance

Outcome Hazard ratio (9+ hrs vs 7–8 hrs) Increase in risk
All-cause mortality 1.51 51%
Heart-related mortality 1.53 53%
Non-heart-related mortality 1.50 50%

What the study cannot tell you

The study is observational, meaning it can identify associations but cannot prove causation. Sleep was self-reported and measured only once, so long-term sleep patterns were not captured. Residual confounding — unmeasured factors such as depression severity, sleep apnea severity, medications, and heart disease severity — remains possible, News-Medical reported.

Heart disease itself was defined by self-report and spanned different conditions: coronary heart disease, another heart condition, or heart attack. Subgroup findings were treated as hypothesis-generating; the heart-related association with long sleep was not significant in adults under 65, possibly because fewer heart-related deaths occurred in that group.

Doctors should ask heart patients about sleep duration

The authors suggest asking about sleep duration is a simple, inexpensive way to identify adults with heart disease who may need further evaluation for contributors such as sleep-disordered breathing or depression.

What researchers want to measure next

Future studies should use objective and repeated sleep measures to determine whether long sleep reflects underlying health vulnerability, existing sleep disorders, or progression of heart disease, the authors state, News-Medical reported. Routine sleep-duration assessment may offer clinicians an additional opportunity to identify elevated-risk patients who would otherwise go unrecognized.

References

  • Sleep duration and cause-specific mortality among US adults with heart disease: A NHIS-NDI linkage cohort study. PLOS One. journals.plos.org
  • News-Medical: Sleeping longer may be a warning sign for heart disease patients.

Consult a qualified healthcare professional about your individual sleep and cardiovascular health.

Photo of author

Health Desk

Health Desk at Archyde.

Ukrainian Forces Strike Kerch Bridge Again, Russian Authorities Close Traffic

South Africa Outlaws Automatic 10% Restaurant Service Charges