UCSF Study Finds E-Scooters Pose Higher Head Injury Risk, Helmet Use Low

E-scooter riders treated at US trauma centers faced a 10% higher adjusted risk of serious head or neck injury than cyclists, even though their overall injuries were less severe, according to a national analysis of 47,102 injured adults published this week in the Journal of the American College of Surgeons.

The study, led by researchers at the University of California, San Francisco, drew on the American College of Surgeons’ National Trauma Data Bank, which collects records from more than 900 emergency departments and trauma centers. News-Medical reported the findings on Tuesday, drawing on cases treated in 2023 and 2024.

The paradox sits at the center of the paper: e-scooter riders had a 7% lower adjusted risk of severe or critical injury overall than bicycle riders, yet a higher risk of damage to the skull, face, and cervical spine — the head and neck region. Helmets, the data show, are the clearest protective factor, and riders are largely not wearing them.

Us e scooters linked to head and neck in
Photo: UA.NEWS

Helmets cut skull fracture risk in e-scooter crashes

  • E-scooter crashes concentrate damage in the head and neck — the areas helmets protect — even when the rest of the injury is milder than a bike crash.
  • Helmet use cut the adjusted risk of skull fracture by 69% among e-scooter riders, yet only 13% of injured e-scooter riders were documented wearing one.
  • Nearly one in five injured e-scooter riders had a blood alcohol level at or above the 0.08% legal driving limit.

The numbers behind the devices

Bicycle riders made up the bulk of the sample: 32,100 cases, or 68%, with a median age of 54 — the oldest group. Twenty-one percent had severe or critical injuries, and 3.2% died in hospital. E-bike riders accounted for 8,744 cases (19%), and e-scooter riders 6,258 cases (13%), News-Medical reported.

After researchers adjusted for rider age, crash type, and other characteristics, e-bike riders’ risk of severe or critical injury did not differ significantly from cyclists’. That matters because e-bike cases rose 44% from 2023 to 2024.

Resource use told a similar story. E-scooter riders had lower adjusted risks of emergency surgery, early blood transfusion, and in-hospital death than cyclists, the study found.

Device Share of cases Severe/critical injury Helmet use documented Alcohol ≥0.08%
Bicycle 68% (32,100 cases) 21% 33% 9.4%
E-bike 19% (8,744 cases) 19% 32% 16%
E-scooter 13% (6,258 cases) 16% 13% 19%

Where and how the crashes happen

The crash contexts differ sharply by device. Only 33% of e-scooter injuries were classified as traffic-related, compared with 72% of bicycle injuries and 74% of e-bike injuries, according to the analysis covered by UA.NEWS. Collisions accounted for 48% of e-scooter injuries, against 63% for bicycles and 59% for e-bikes.

Experts warn of head injury risk linked with E-scooters — 13 ON YOUR SIDE

That pattern may explain the head and neck concentration. A rider standing upright on a small-wheeled scooter who falls forward has little between the skull and the pavement, while a cyclist thrown from a bike more often absorbs impact across the chest, extremities, and pelvis — body regions where the study found e-scooter riders had lower adjusted injury risk.

Helmet use was associated with a 12% lower adjusted risk of severe injury and fewer craniofacial fractures across all devices. For e-scooter riders specifically, the association was stronger: a 69% lower adjusted risk of skull fracture and a 45% lower risk of facial fracture.

Alcohol told a different story. A blood alcohol level of 0.08% or higher — the US legal threshold for impaired driving — was documented in 19% of injured e-scooter riders, 16% of e-bike riders, and 9.4% of cyclists. After statistical adjustment, that level was not significantly associated with severe or critical injury, though the researchers cautioned the percentages may understate intoxication rates.

What the data cannot say

The analysis included only injured adults treated at participating trauma centers. Details such as riding speed and road conditions were also absent, the researchers acknowledged.

That limitation cuts both ways. The 10% higher head and neck risk for e-scooter riders describes injured people who reached trauma centers — not the odds that any given ride ends in injury. A device with fewer but more head-focused crashes could still look different from one with many minor incidents.

Riders reduce injury risk by wearing helmets

“You don’t want to drive a car while inebriated or intoxicated.”

Study findings shape micromobility regulation

The findings arrive as cities and states weigh how to regulate rapidly growing micromobility fleets, and as hospitals — the study’s stated aim — use injury-pattern data to refine trauma care. With e-bike cases up 44% from 2023 to 2024, helmet use was still uncommon among injured riders.

References

  • Abbasi B, Chu PW, Carlisle MN, et al. Micromobility Injury Patterns and Resource Use in US Trauma Centers. Journal of the American College of Surgeons, published November 17, 2026. doi:10.1097/XCS.0000000000002203
  • News-Medical. E-scooters linked to increased head and neck injury risk.
  • UA.NEWS. US e-scooters linked to higher head and neck injury risk.

Readers with injury-related symptoms should consult a qualified healthcare professional.

Photo of author

Health Desk

Health Desk at Archyde.

Finland Beat Republic of Ireland U21s in Extra Time

Two CN Rail Crew Members Hospitalized After Train Derails Into Skeena River, B.C.