Van Gogh Painting Sells for $190.4 Million After Settlement

Nazi-era heirs got their claim settled, and a Vincent van Gogh canvas sold for $190.4 million at Sotheby’s on Wednesday night — but only after an eleventh-hour settlement rescued the sale from a dispute that surfaced less than a week earlier.

The 1890 painting, “Châtaigniers en Fleurs (Blossoming Chestnut Trees),” set an auction record for the artist in a packed Manhattan salesroom, the report of the sale said.

The record was, in effect, secured before bidding began. The work carried a guarantee, and auctioneer Oliver Barker spent more than three minutes trying to draw new bidders as the room stayed silent.

Patrick Drahi, Sotheby’s controlling shareholder, watched from behind the audience with what the account described as a dour expression.

A Claim Surfaced Days Before the Sale

Jewish heirs of Samuel Fischer, a German Jewish publisher, staked a claim to the painting just last week. They said it had been sold in the 1930s under the duress of Nazi persecution.

After a marathon negotiating session on Monday, the heirs and the current sellers, Argentina’s Blaquier-Arrieta family, reached an undisclosed agreement that let the auction proceed. Sotheby’s declined to disclose the terms of the deal between the Argentine family and Fischer’s heirs, whose family sold the painting in 1936.

Gunnar Schnabel, the lawyer for Fischer’s heirs, watched the sale unfold. He issued a statement afterward.

The family hopes that the considerable public interest in this case, and its fast and fair and just resolution, may offer some encouragement to other families who have faced persecution during the Nazi era.

Gunnar Schnabel, lawyer for Fischer’s heirs

The Sale Fell $54 Million Short of Its Estimate

The van Gogh was the crown jewel of the Blaquier-Arrieta collection, a trove of Impressionist and modern art assembled by Argentine sugar heiress Nelly Arrieta de Blaquier and her husband, Carlos Pedro Blaquier. Van Gogh created the light-dappled street scene just four days after he arrived in pastoral Auvers. He had spent a year in a psychiatric asylum.

“We've been dreaming of this one for 20 years,” said Simon Shaw, Sotheby’s senior adviser, of the collection.

The dream could have become a nightmare.

All told, the 12 works in the family’s collection sold for $412 million against Sotheby’s estimate of $450 million. Without auction house premiums, the house fell $54 million short of its predicted sales, the Seattle Times carried in its edition.

The settlement, though, ended in reward. The result surpassed van Gogh’s previous auction record of $117.2 million (about $133 million in today’s dollars). Christie’s set that mark in 2022 for a landscape from the collection of Microsoft co-founder Paul Allen.

Before the auction, Sotheby’s reduced its risk: it found buyers who agreed to buy all of the works, including the van Gogh, at a set price. That held even if no other bidders came forward.

Lot Result Estimate
Van Gogh, “Châtaigniers en Fleurs” (1890) $190.4 million, with fees —
Cézanne, “Arlequin” (1888-90) $111 million, with fees around $120 million
Blaquier-Arrieta collection, 12 works $412 million $450 million

Wednesday night’s van Gogh sale matched that of another van Gogh from the Blaquier-Arrieta collection, according to people familiar with the deal. Christie’s sold that work in a private transaction less than a year ago. The 1888 work, “Le Zouave,” a portrait of a swaggering soldier, reached around $190 million.

Experts Ask Why Sotheby’s Did Not Alert the Heirs

Some restitution experts wondered why Sotheby’s had not reached out earlier to alert the heirs of the previous owner, the report said.

Sotheby’s has not explained why it did not alert Fischer’s heirs sooner.

Earlier coverage: Sotheby's Urged to Withdraw $180 Million Van Gogh From Auction

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

Ashley Sanchez Wins 2026 NWSL MVP After Record-Tying 20-Goal Season