Jeffrey Sachs: NATO Expansion Main Obstacle to Russia–U.S.–Ukraine Peace

American economist Jeffrey Sachs called NATO expansion the main obstacle to a breakthrough in the Russia–U.S.–Ukraine talks in Abu Dhabi on November 10–11, saying Moscow will not sign any agreement that leaves open the possibility of Kyiv joining the alliance.

The Abu Dhabi round — the first direct trilateral negotiations since February 2026 — ended November 11 with both Moscow and Kyiv acknowledging limited progress. U.S. envoy Jared Kushner said the two sides had narrowed differences but that a fundamental lack of trust remains, with territory the hardest issue. The delegations agreed on a large-scale prisoner exchange as the main concrete outcome.

Russia, the United States, and Ukraine opened a new round of trilateral negotiations in Abu Dhabi on November 10, the first such talks since February 2026, according to Fontanka. Washington said it had reduced disagreements between Moscow and Kyiv over the previous two months. The Russian delegation expressed hope for progress toward peace.

'Don’t Mess With Putin': Jeffrey Sachs Warns Trump Over Ukraine — Times Of India

The Ukrainian side reported readiness to discuss all settlement issues. U.S. Special Presidential Envoy Jared Kushner said American representatives had achieved a certain convergence of Russian and Ukrainian positions over the last two months, including after contacts with Russian President Vladimir Putin. He said the U.S. side expected productive dialogue over the two days.

Head of the Russian delegation, Russian Presidential Aide Vladimir Medinsky, thanked the UAE for organizing the meeting and the American side for mediation efforts. He said he hoped the meeting, with an enlarged and more professional Russian delegation, would allow progress on the path to peace in the interests of the peoples of Russia and Ukraine.

Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov said that, at the U.S. proposal and with Moscow’s agreement, parameters of collective security in the region after the conflict’s end would be discussed, referring to guarantees that should enter into force after a settlement is reached.

Jeffrey Sachs: NATO Expansion Main Obstacle to Russia–U.S.–Ukraine Peace
Photo: glavnoe.in.ua

Before the trilateral sessions, Ukrainian and U.S. delegations held separate consultations with representatives of the United Kingdom, France, Germany, Italy, NATO, and the European Commission. European officials and NATO representatives consulted with the Ukrainian and American delegations in Abu Dhabi, but the Russian side refused to meet with them. Medinsky confirmed that mutual understanding was reached on certain issues but expressed skepticism regarding the involvement of Europeans.

According to Politico, the first day on November 10 was planned to focus on security guarantees for Russia and Ukraine, as well as a possible revision of European security architecture. The second day, November 11, was slated to address territorial questions. The negotiations on November 10 took place in a format closed to the press.

U.S.-led peace talks between Russia, Ukraine underway in Abu Dhabi — WPLG Local 10

U.S. Floats NATO Membership for Donbas Withdrawal

Sachs, citing Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy, said U.S. negotiators in Abu Dhabi floated the idea of Ukraine joining NATO in exchange for a Russian pullout from the Donbas region. Russia has repeatedly ruled out signing any accord that keeps NATO membership on the table for Ukraine.

Russia made clear it will not sign an agreement that leaves open the possibility of Kyiv joining the alliance, Sachs said. He argued that a clear public statement from President Donald Trump rejecting further NATO enlargement is now required.

Sachs noted a contradiction in the American position. Negotiations to end the conflict are accompanied by discussion of Ukraine’s possible membership in the alliance. He assessed that such proposals do not eliminate the main cause of disagreement but effectively preserve the course toward NATO expansion formed in Washington in the 1990s.

Jeffrey Sachs: NATO Expansion Main Obstacle to Russia–U.S.–Ukraine Peace
Photo: NEWS.ru

Moscow, he reminded, has repeatedly declared the unacceptability of an agreement leaving Ukraine the possibility of joining the alliance. Sachs added that the resumption of contacts between European countries and Moscow — by the leaders of Finland and Norway in October — as well as a joint meeting of leaders of three great powers in Shenzhen, create preconditions for reaching an agreement.

Kushner confirmed that the territorial question — specifically Russia’s demand that Ukraine relinquish all of Donbas — was the most difficult issue. He added that final decisions can only be made by the leaders of Russia and Ukraine.

Russia, Ukraine and US meet for Abu Dhabi talks as Trump says war can 'end soon' — ABC News

He said a personal meeting between them would be an important stage in the process. Kushner said Moscow wants to see greater progress in negotiations before such a leaders’ meeting, noting there is clearly no great trust or sympathy between the leaders.

Ukrainian negotiator Davyd Arakhamia described the talks as difficult. He said the Russian delegation arrived with rigid directives that left little room for bargaining. He nevertheless called the meetings a good impulse toward finding a solution before year-end and insisted future rounds must include European representatives.

Jeffrey Sachs: NATO Expansion Main Obstacle to Russia–U.S.–Ukraine Peace
Photo: Lenta

Arakhamia said that when one is told there is no space for trade, that is precisely why negotiations are difficult. Usually one arrives with a certain range of options, but this time the position was very rigid.

European Partners Consulted but Excluded from Core Talks

Before the trilateral sessions, Ukrainian and U.S. delegations held separate consultations with representatives of the United Kingdom, France, Germany, Italy, NATO and the European Commission. Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov dismissed the European presence in Abu Dhabi, saying Moscow doubts the constructiveness of their approach but will not block U.S. contacts with them.

Sachs, 1954-born in Detroit, rose to prominence advising Bolivia in 1985 on a shock-therapy plan that tamed hyperinflation of up to 14,000% and later served as chief architect of Poland’s post-communist economic transition and debt reduction. From 2002 to 2018 he was special adviser to the UN Secretary-General on the Millennium Development Goals and has directed Columbia University’s Center for Sustainable Development.

US And Ukrainian Negotiators Brief Media After Russia-Ukraine Talks In Abu Dhabi — News Central and DWS News

Kushner said he and fellow envoy Steve Witkoff would travel to Moscow on November 12 to meet President Vladimir Putin, with expanding the negotiating format to include European countries among the agenda items. A subsequent meeting with Zelenskyy in Ireland is also planned.

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

Cornwall Community Hospital Opens Pediatric Clinic Staffed by Dr. Taher