Michael Atherton: Pat Cummins Faces No Immediate Threat as Captain Despite Sandpapergate Fallout

Michael Atherton says Pat Cummins faces no immediate threat as Australia’s Test captain despite fresh Sandpapergate revelations, but the former England opener warned on the Sky Sports Cricket Podcast this week that public opinion could yet turn the Australian skipper’s position untenable.

The headline word — “untenable” — belongs to the Sky Sports framing of the question, and Atherton’s answer was a qualified no. “I don’t think so, yet,” he told the Sky Sports Cricket Podcast. “But the public reaction will be interesting because the sympathy now is almost going towards the lads who took the fall, particularly Bancroft.”

Why does this matter now? Because the 2018 ball-tampering scandal has been reopened from inside the dressing room itself. Usman Khawaja’s claims — that the whole squad knew tampering was happening on the 2018 tour of South Africa — were flatly rejected by Cummins at a press conference on November 13, where the captain called them “100 per cent wrong”.

Days later, Cameron Bancroft backed the allegations with a 4,000-word statement and said Cummins’ denials left him “angry, betrayed and alone”.

Sandpapergate: Michael Atherton believes Pat Cummins won
Photo: gigantum.net

Atherton says resignation calls should not be priced as imminent

  • Captaincy futures markets: Atherton says the resignation calls should not be priced as imminent — Cricket Australia’s interim chair David Boone and chief executive Todd Greenberg have both publicly backed Cummins, with Boone clear about a week ago and both reiterating that support on Wednesday.
  • Squad continuity: With no immediate threat to his role, Australia’s captain Cummins — named in Bancroft’s account alongside the pace attack of Mitchell Starc and Josh Hazlewood — retains the support Atherton described.
  • Reputation exposure: Sponsors and broadcasters face a story that dominates headlines around Australia’s ODI series against England, a factor Atherton flagged when describing the atmosphere as “febrile”.

The support inside Cricket Australia

Cummins has what he called a lot of “credit in the bank” for transforming the team’s culture and keeping Australia “at the top of the tree”.

He pointed to the mechanics of the backing: David Boone, Cricket Australia’s interim chair, was clear about support roughly a week before the podcast, and Boone and chief executive Todd Greenberg reiterated it “very strongly” on Wednesday, Sky Sports reported.

Cummins’ own management has issued multiple statements since Bancroft’s, saying there was “nothing in the [Bancroft’s] statement that hasn’t been answered” and that the captain has been “consistent and adamant” from day one.

But Atherton also issued the warning that organisations are rarely loyal in perpetuity. “Organisations are pretty fickle, aren’t they? They support you until you don’t,” he said, adding that if the public turns, “that can be a different thing.”

Who knew what, and who paid

The asymmetry of punishment sits at the heart of the renewed controversy. Bancroft, banned for nine months after the 2018 saga, claims sandpaper was used not only in the third Test in Cape Town but in the second Test in Port Elizabeth as well.

He recalled conversations with the fast-bowling group — Cummins, Starc, Hazlewood and Mitchell Marsh — about “whether it was swinging enough”, and says the whole playing and coaching group was present when media manager Kate Hutchinson voiced opposition to the plan.

Development When Detail
Cummins rejects Khawaja’s claims November 13 Called them “100 per cent wrong” at a press conference
Bancroft’s statement After the press conference 4,000 words; says denials left him “angry, betrayed and alone”
Cricket Australia backing Week before the podcast, reiterated Wednesday Boone and Greenberg reaffirmed support for Cummins

Atherton said doubt remains on the central question. “There is still some doubt about exactly who knew what,” he said. But he judged two things clear from Khawaja’s book, Sabr, and Bancroft’s statement: the institutional pressure and win-at-all-costs mentality in the build-up to the South Africa tour. Greenberg himself, Atherton noted, conceded Cricket Australia bore some accountability for that environment.

What happens next is a test of sentiment rather than governance. Champlain the moment as the Sky Sports cameras did: they were chasing Cummins on the day Atherton spoke, an image he read as giving a sense of crisis.

His closing caution was that sympathy — not evidence — may decide the captaincy: if it stays with “the lads who took the fall”, it moves against the other camp, “of which Cummins is one”.

“That gives a sense of crisis, doesn’t it? But I don’t know. Maybe I’m wrong, but I don’t see that [his resignation] happening immediately,” Atherton said.

Photo of author

Sport Desk

Sport Desk at Archyde.

US Labor Department Proposes Five Weekly Job-Search Activities Rule for Unemployment Benefits

SpaceX Catches Starship Upper Stage in First Orbital Recovery