Dublin – Migrant rights organisations will tell TDs today that Ireland’s planned citizenship reforms risk working against the country’s own economic interests, The Journal reported.
The Oireachtas Justice Committee begins pre-legislative scrutiny of the General Scheme of the Irish Nationality and Citizenship (Amendment) Bill 2026 this morning, with representatives from several migrant rights organisations appearing before members.
The bill, announced by Justice Minister Jim O’Callaghan in September, would tighten existing citizenship rules. Among its central provisions: the stretch of reckonable residency a person needs before applying would rise from five years to eight.
In opening statements seen by The Journal, the organisations argue the changes lack an evidence base. Sonya Donnelly, a barrister with Nasc, the Migrant and Refugee Rights Centre, will tell committee members the bill should not proceed in its current form. She argues no convincing evidence has been presented that extending the waiting period would improve integration or strengthen the integrity of the immigration system.
The critique lands as Ireland faces acute workforce shortages. Colm O’Gorman, chairperson of the Open Community, an organisation working with refugees and displaced people, will tell TDs and senators the bill risks “undermining integration and working against Ireland’s wider social and economic interests.” His opening statement, submitted to the committee, frames the government’s approach as internally contradictory.
Eight years, while Germany cuts to five
Donnelly’s submission points to a comparison the government may find uncomfortable: the proposed eight-year requirement would set Ireland apart from other European and OECD countries. Germany, she notes, recently moved in the opposite direction, cutting its naturalisation residence requirement from eight years to five.
The timing matters. The organisations’ submissions offer no counter-evidence that a longer wait produces better integration outcomes – because, they argue, none has been produced at all.
Donnelly flags a second concern: the bill’s impact on refugees and stateless persons, and on non-EEA nationals who have no statutory right to permanent residence in Ireland. For those groups, she argues, citizenship is the principal route to long-term security. Eight years of reckonable residency is a long time to live without it.
Citizenship “conditional on financial means”
The sharpest criticism targets the bill’s “economic self-sufficiency” requirement, under which an applicant must demonstrate they have no reliance on any social assistance. Donnelly will tell the committee this risks making citizenship conditional on financial means rather than a person’s connection and contribution to Ireland.
“Accessing lawful social welfare living in local authority housing, or receiving supports such as HAP, should not disqualify someone from citizenship, especially in a country with an acute housing shortage.”
That quote, from her written statement to the committee, carries particular weight given the housing context: HAP supports tens of thousands of households, and a person receiving it would, under the drafted rules, face disqualification from naturalisation.
According to Donnelly, the measures could produce a two-tier system in which those with financial security are chiefly the ones able to obtain citizenship, while women, carers, people with disabilities and low-paid workers bear a disproportionate share of the disadvantage.
O’Gorman’s submission presses the same point from a different angle. “We see no compelling evidence that extending the residence requirement from five to eight years is necessary or justified, nor do we believe that citizenship should depend on income or whether someone has needed housing or social welfare support,” he wrote.
“A person’s contribution to Irish society cannot simply be measured by their earnings.”
Ireland needs inward migration to address critical workforce shortages in construction, healthcare and other essential sectors. Making citizenship harder for people who have chosen to build lives here is, he writes, “illogical and counterproductive.”
“We cannot expect people to come here and help build our homes and deliver essential services while making it harder for them and their families to build a permanent future here.”
Power over revocation
A third flashpoint sits further into the bill: the rules governing revocation of citizenship. Nasc contended that, as currently drafted, the bill would place an excessive concentration of authority in this area with the justice minister.
What happens from here is the standard Oireachtas sequence: the committee hears the organisations today as it begins pre-legislative scrutiny of the General Scheme, and the process continues from there. The Irish Nationality and Citizenship (Amendment) Bill 2026 was announced by Justice Minister Jim O’Callaghan in September.