Mother Describes Grief at Inquest Into Law Student’s Death After Moderna Booster

Twenty-one-year-old law student Natalie Boyce died at Melbourne’s Alfred hospital on March 27, 2022, five weeks after receiving a Moderna COVID-19 booster — and her mother has told a coronial inquest she was denied access to her critically ill daughter at three hospitals in the final weeks of her life.

The Coroners Court of Victoria began hearings on Monday into the death of Ms Boyce, who was in her fourth year of a Bachelor of Laws and Commerce at Deakin University. According to News.com.au, medical experts told the inquest that the severity of her condition meant there was a “high likelihood she still would have died” even if the myocarditis had been picked up earlier.

Counsel assisting the coroner, Rachel Ellyard, told the court Ms Boyce was a fit and active student, working four days a week, who had planned to travel to Greece for her 22nd birthday in June 2022, according to Newsfinale. Her mother, Deborah Hamilton, described her as happy, healthy and energetic, and a dedicated worker who had already accomplished a great deal at a young age.

Ms Boyce had received two doses of Pfizer in September and October 2021, followed by the Moderna booster on February 18, in order to keep her job at fleet management firm LeasePlan and attend in-person classes under Victoria’s sweeping vaccine mandates, News.com.au reported. The following day she fainted and struck her head.

Over the next two weeks she saw her general practitioner, attended Angliss Hospital and Monash Health’s Clayton campus, and presented at Mulgrave Private Hospital on March 5, where an electrocardiogram indicated possible pericarditis. Her health deteriorated rapidly and she was transferred to The Alfred, where doctors placed her on life support within hours.

According to Newsfinale, Ms Hamilton drove her daughter to Mulgrave after calling triple-0 and being told an ambulance would not be available straight away. She briefly spoke to Natalie as paramedics prepared to transfer her.

Healthy law student died within weeks of covid jab as
Photo: newsfinale.com

“Tragically, as Ms Hamilton has explained in her statement, that was the last opportunity Natalie and her mother had to speak to each other,” Ms Ellyard said.

Ms Boyce remained at The Alfred for about three weeks without speaking to her mother again, and died on March 27 after suffering cardiac arrest during an MRI scan.

Appearing before the inquest on Thursday morning, Ms Hamilton read a coronial impact statement, telling the court she still had frequent nightmares and struggled with ordinary day-to-day life, News.com.au reported.

“Natalie’s death has caused me and my family immeasurable grief, pain and loss,” she said.

She said at Natalie’s funeral two ribbons were attached to her wrists, one joining her to her mother and the other to her older brother Hayden. The ribbons were cut, and Ms Hamilton now carries her piece with her, along with a ring she gave Natalie for her 18th birthday.

“Natalie had a wicked sense of humour — she said to me, ‘You have to be nice to me as I’ll be choosing your nursing home.’ Instead I had to arrange her funeral at 21, and now all I have is her ashes,” she said.

Ms Hamilton, who raised Natalie and Hayden as a single mother, said she was “denied the opportunity to advocate for her and support her”.

“I believe the outcome may have been different if I had been allowed to be there and speak up for her,” she said.

She had earlier given evidence to a Senate committee in May 2023, telling senators she felt powerless throughout her daughter’s treatment, according to Newsfinale. “I was not allowed into the hospital because of government Covid regulations,” she said, referring to Natalie’s time at Angliss. At Monash, she said she still had text messages in which her daughter pleaded for her to come and stay with her, and claimed Natalie was left sitting in a chair for eight hours during a visit lasting about 16 hours.

At Mulgrave, staff allowed her to remain, but after following the ambulance to The Alfred at about 2.30am she was refused entry and told to go home. During Natalie’s three weeks in intensive care, visits were initially restricted to one hour on three days each week, later increased to one hour per day.

Interventional cardiologist Nicholas Cox told the inquest that doctors at Monash Hospital missed an opportunity for an “earlier diagnosis” on March 3, 2022, via an ECG, troponin test or chest X-ray, News.com.au reported. While there was “a significant chance she would not have survived regardless of what treatment was given, there would have been some chance of a different outcome had different treatment been initiated earlier”, he said.

Associate Professor Mark Adams, former head of cardiology at Sydney’s Royal Prince Alfred Hospital, called as an independent expert witness for Monash Health, disputed that. “Supportive treatment does not alter the trajectory of the disease itself,” he said.

“In fact, sadly, I don’t think there was anything at any point that would have changed the trajectory of the disease,” he said.

Professor Adams also defended the “draconian” pandemic-era policies that kept loved ones from dying family members.

“These were very difficult times,” he said. “I felt really terrible for the patients and their families … it was a terrible time but unfortunately it really just was a terrible time medically as well. I think some of those harsh measures probably prevented many infections at the time. I don’t know what they could have done differently.”

The Alfred, where Ms Boyce spent her final weeks, is one of Melbourne’s oldest hospitals, founded in 1871 and named after Prince Alfred after he survived an assassination attempt during a royal visit to Australia.

It is one of two major adult trauma centres in Victoria and houses the largest intensive care unit in the country. In 1956 it became the first hospital in Australia to place a patient on cardiopulmonary bypass during cardiac surgery, and it today hosts both adult and pediatric lung transplantation services.

Coroner Catherine Fitzgerald will investigate whether Ms Boyce had myocarditis, an inflammation of the heart muscle, and what caused the condition, Newsfinale reported.

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

Tulsa Police, Animal Services Honored as Heroes for Rescuing 30+ Dogs, Cats in Cruelty Case