The Supreme Court on Monday refused to hear the Trump administration’s appeal seeking to cut off research grants to University of California professors, letting stand a 9th Circuit ruling that the terminations violated the First Amendment.
The justices denied review without comment or dissent.
The case, Trump vs. Thakur, began when federal agencies sent form letters in 2025 terminating grants that contained keywords like “diversity,” “equity” or “environmental justice” — a list that included UC Berkeley’s work editing and publishing Mark Twain’s writings and a UCLA study of how information spreads on social media.
Six UC professors filed a class-action suit in June 2025. The justices let the 9th Circuit’s ruling stand, which held the government may not use “its power to punish or suppress disfavored expression.”
The Bottom Line
- The Supreme Court declined, without comment, to review the 9th Circuit’s finding that the grant cuts violated the First Amendment.
- Professor Claudia Polsky says the ruling’s effect extends beyond the grants at issue, protecting hundreds of millions more in reinstated grants.
- The case is not over — the denial is not a final ruling, and a separate Justice Department suit seeks more than $2 billion back from UC.
Why a One-Week Denial Carries Weight
The administration's petition was under consideration for just one week before it was turned down. The Supreme Court offered no explanation, and no justice dissented — a quiet end to a high-stakes request.
Solicitor Gen. D. John Sauer had argued the 9th Circuit’s view of the First Amendment was wrong and could limit the government’s authority over spending and grants. “Vast sums of taxpayer money are at stake,” he wrote, noting the UC system took in more than $4 billion in federal grant money in 2024.
“If left to stand, the 9th Circuit’s decision will establish precedent forcing taxpayers to waste countless dollars on private projects promoting ideologies that their public stewards reject,” he wrote.
On the other side, UC Berkeley Law Dean Erwin Chemerinsky urged the court to deny the appeal, arguing that past decisions make clear “ideologically driven attempts to suppress a particular point of view are presumptively unconstitutional in funding.”
Claudia Polsky, the UC Berkeley law professor who represents the researchers, called the decision “very consequential.” Although the appeal covered only National Science Foundation and National Endowment for the Humanities grants, she said it also protects hundreds of millions in reinstated UC grants from the National Institutes of Health and the Defense and Transportation departments.
The Money at Stake, Grant by Grant
For a story about constitutional doctrine, the numbers do a lot of talking. Monday’s action covers one slice of a much larger fight — one that could affect several billion dollars in government grants nationwide.
🚨 JUST IN: The Supreme Court just REFUSED to hear President Trump's appeal to cut off DEI research grants — which means activist judges are effectively UPHELD in forcing tens of millions of taxpayer dollars to fund DEI grants, for now UNBELIEVABLE! The justices denied review… pic.twitter.com/6WVS73hv1y
| Item | Amount | Detail |
|---|---|---|
| NEH and NSF grants targeted | ~$150 million | Terminated over DEI-related keywords |
| UC federal grant income (2024) | More than $4 billion | Cited by Solicitor General Sauer |
| UCLA grants restored | ~$581 million | By Judge Rita F. Lin, August–September 2025 |
| Thakur EPA grant | $1.3 million | Wildfire smoke study; case’s named plaintiff |
| DOJ repayment demand | More than $2 billion | Sought in separate suit against UC |
The named plaintiff is Neeta Thakur, a UC San Francisco researcher whose $1.3-million Environmental Protection Agency grant studied the effect of wildfire smoke on California communities. Her professors were told their projects no longer fit “agency priorities.”
What the Ruling Does — and Doesn’t — Settle
Monday’s order is a win, but not a final ruling; the 9th Circuit in May had limited the UC case to a 1st Amendment claim after the Supreme Court narrowed claims in larger health and education grant cases. The Supreme Court’s narrowing of claims pushed claims for canceled grants to the Court of Federal Claims, leaving the First Amendment claim as the issue the appeals court decided.
The appeals court drew a line the administration disputed: officials may choose to fund some programs and not others, but they may not discriminate against qualified grant recipients because of their viewpoint. The administration had asked the justices to resolve whether the First Amendment prohibits the government from considering the viewpoints advanced by academic research when awarding or terminating competitive grants. That question now stays unanswered at the high court.
The ruling’s reach also extends past the researchers who originally filed it. In separate orders in the same case, U.S. District Judge Rita F. Lin in San Francisco restored about $581 million in UCLA research grants in August and September 2025, which the administration had frozen over allegations of campus antisemitism.
Months later, the Justice Department sued UC, alleging UCLA tolerated antisemitic harassment of students and seeking repayment of more than $2 billion in research grants; UC has asked the court to dismiss the case.
Why Culture Watchers Should Care
It’s easy to file this under “court news” and scroll past. But look at what was actually on the chopping block: UC Berkeley’s work editing and publishing Mark Twain’s writings and a UCLA study of how information spreads on social media. Those are cultural-infrastructure projects, the kind that feed the documentaries, book adaptations and public-history programming that studios and streamers license downstream.
A UC spokesperson said the decision “preserves an important victory for the UC researchers whose critical work and federal grants were targeted. It supports the principle that research funding decisions should be based on merit, not politics.”
Supreme Court turns down Trump's plan to cut off UC research grants that promote DEI https://t.co/mvCmH9Hp5c
The 9th Circuit’s May opinion, limiting the UC case to its First Amendment claim, remains the operative ruling. The administration’s docket in Trump vs. Thakur now reflects Monday’s denial.
The University of California, the defendant in the Justice Department’s parallel suit, is far larger than the two campuses named in the case. Founded on March 23, 1868, in Oakland, the public research university system grew to ten campuses — from Berkeley to Merced — and now enrolls 299,407 students with 26,100 faculty members.
Its researchers have won 75 Nobel Prizes as of 2025, and the university manages or co-manages three national laboratories for the Department of Energy, including Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory and Los Alamos National Laboratory.
Where does it go from here? The underlying case continues, and the Justice Department’s suit against UC sits unresolved. The next dated move is the district court’s handling of UC’s motion to dismiss — a decision that will tell us whether Monday’s quiet denial was a detour or the turning point.
More on Trump
Supreme Court declines Trump’s effort to gut UC research grants that support DEI LEARN MORE: https://t.co/QhlZf2XNyt pic.twitter.com/REd119kxx9
Supreme Court rejects Trump bid to revive UC research grant cuts https://t.co/oLGwCock0J
Keep reading