UCSF Doctors Rally for Stronger Policies to Protect Patients in ICE Custody

More than 50 doctors, nurses, and immigrant rights advocates rallied Tuesday morning outside a University of California Board of Regents meeting at UCSF Mission Bay, demanding systemwide policies to protect patients brought to hospitals in Immigration and Customs Enforcement custody — a demand UC says it has partially met through state guidelines it has not confirmed are being trained or enforced.

The rally, reported by Mission Local, was organized by resident physicians who say ICE agents have refused to leave examination rooms, blocked patients from contacting family or attorneys, and pressured doctors to discharge patients before a safe medical discharge plan was in place. Between them, the UCSF residents who took part say they have cared for roughly 10 patients in ICE custody at San Francisco hospitals over the past year.

Why does this matter clinically, not just politically? Because the moment a patient enters an emergency department, the clinical priorities — privacy, honest history-taking, continuity of medication, a safe discharge — depend on trust. When a uniformed agent stands in the exam room, that architecture collapses. The doctors at Tuesday’s rally are asking the university to rebuild it with binding rules rather than guidelines alone.

Custody changes the clinical exam

  • Custody changes the exam. When a patient arrives with an agent, clinicians cannot assume the private conversation that normally underpins diagnosis — medication adherence, symptoms, fears — can happen at all.
  • Discharge is a medical decision. Sending a patient back to detention without a verified plan for insulin, blood pressure medication, or follow-up can turn a treatable condition into an ICU admission.
  • Fear keeps sick people home. Emergency physicians report patients delaying care for dangerous conditions because they believe a hospital visit could be reported to immigration authorities. Hospitals do not report patients; the fear itself causes harm.

What doctors say happened in the exam room

Dr. Francesco Sergi, a resident physician at the University of California, San Francisco, described caring for a young man brought to a San Francisco emergency department earlier this year by immigration enforcement agents.

Overcome with fear, the young man had no way of knowing where his family was, and they had no idea he had been taken to the hospital — nor when he might see them next. Staff managed to contact his relatives and let them know he was alive and in the hospital, Mission Local reported. Other patients in custody, Sergi said, have not been so lucky.

Without clear institutional rules, Sergi said, “a lot of folks are just unsure what to actually do in these contexts.”

Dr. SatKartar Khalsa, a fourth-year emergency medicine resident at San Francisco General Hospital who serves as a regional vice president of the resident physicians’ union, explained to Mission Local during a Monday interview that agents have on occasion declined requests to exit examination rooms, meaning staff had to negotiate before they could see patients in private.

Speaking with Mission Local on Monday, SatKartar Khalsa described a tension that hangs over the air, across the entire floor and the entire hospital whenever ICE is accompanying a patient, noting that it generates an enormous amount of fear.

Khalsa and Sergi recounted cases of diabetes patients who ended up needing intensive care after missing their insulin, along with patients whose hypertension went untreated until it damaged their organs.

The legal gap the rally is trying to close

Here is the structural problem. State and local laws restrict immigration enforcement inside hospitals, but California Senate Bill 81, enacted in September 2025, still allows ICE agents to accompany people who are already in their custody to medical appointments. The policy gap is not about agents hunting for someone inside a hospital — existing UC rules largely cover that, Khalsa said — but about agents standing beside a patient they brought in themselves.

The residents’ union has proposed an eight-page model policy requiring all hospital staff to ask agents to leave during medical examinations, facilitating confidential communication with relatives and lawyers, and barring agents from making medical decisions for patients.

On one crucial point it reaches beyond what state guidance calls for: obtaining written guarantees that patients will get their medications and follow-up care before being sent back to immigration detention. As written in the proposal, ICE would be obligated to name the medical provider who will handle a patient’s ongoing care and to give written guarantees that prescribed medications, equipment and follow-up treatment would be available.

A shortcoming the sources themselves point out: neither the guidelines, nor the proposed policies, spell out how hospitals could force detention facilities to make good on promised care once patients are moved. That enforcement question remains open.

UC adopts attorney general guidelines

In an emailed statement, a UC Health spokesperson wrote that “UC is committed to providing safe, compassionate care to every patient, regardless of immigration status,” and said UC has adopted the California Attorney General’s September 2026 guidelines as systemwide policy, which require hospitals to safeguard patient information and instruct staff to alert administrators and seek advice from legal counsel whenever immigration agents ask to enter facilities, see patients or obtain medical records.

Under those guidelines, healthcare workers are told to ask agents to step out during examinations and to notify hospital administrators or legal counsel if they refuse, and they call for reasonable efforts to verify that immigration facilities can meet patients’ medical needs, while also providing for escalation and documentation if a safe discharge cannot be confirmed.

What the statement did not specify — and what the residents are pressing the Board of Regents to answer — is how individual hospitals have implemented those provisions and whether staff have been trained on them. Guidelines on paper, the residents argue, are not the same as a nurse knowing exactly what to say when an agent refuses to leave a room.

Precedents elsewhere in California

This is not uncharted territory. Some UCSF nurses at the rally, who declined to give their names, also cited fears for healthcare workers themselves.

Policy layer What it requires Key limitation
California SB 81 (Sept. 2025) Restricts enforcement in hospitals Agents may still accompany patients in their custody
State AG guidelines (Sept. 2026, adopted by UC) Protect patient information; direct staff to notify administrators and consult legal counsel; request agents leave exams; report refusals to hospital administrators or legal counsel; reasonable efforts to confirm immigration facilities can meet medical needs No confirmed staff training; neither guidelines nor proposed policies establish how hospitals could compel detention facilities to deliver promised care after transfer

Physicians urge patients to seek care

No reader should take the wrong lesson from this story. Emergency rooms treat everyone regardless of immigration status, and both Sergi and Khalsa stressed that they have never seen an ICE raid take place at a hospital, and that no patient should let fear of immigration consequences — whatever their status — stop them from seeking medical care.

“We really want to set limits so that all of our patients can feel safe when they’re accessing care,” Sergi said. If cost, status, or fear is making you or someone you know avoid a hospital, the clinical advice from the physicians in this story is direct: seek care. WE IGNORE NOTHING — but the safest course, per these sources, is treatment now.

Where this goes next

The demand now sits with the UC Board of Regents, which met Tuesday at UCSF’s Mission Bay campus as residents, nurses, and community members marched outside chanting “ICE Out,” Mission Local reported.

The Regents have not publicly stated whether they will adopt the union’s model policy or how the Attorney General’s guidelines will be trained into practice at each campus hospital. Until that is answered, the residents’ core clinical objection — that a safe discharge cannot be verified once a patient leaves their ward — remains unresolved.

References

  • Mission Local — At rally, S.F. doctors and staff say ICE agents are putting patients in danger (primary report; interviews with Dr. Francesco Sergi and Dr. SatKartar Khalsa; UC Health statement)
  • California Attorney General — Healthcare guidance on immigration enforcement (Senate Bill 81)

Disclaimer: This article is reported journalism, not medical advice. For personal health concerns, consult a qualified healthcare provider.

Photo of author

Health Desk

Health Desk at Archyde.

Jordyn Woods Turns 10-Minute Makeup Fix Into Beauty Inc Awards Look

UC Irvine Brings 3-0 Start, 57.7 Rebounds to Stanford for First Road Test