World Bank Board Urged to Review IFC $210M BUA Cement Approval Over Emissions Gaps

In Gidan Dare, a farming community beside the BUA Cement plant in northwest Nigeria, wells that once struck water at three or four metres now require seventy or more metres before anyone strikes anything, according to an account published by AllAfrica.

Residents also describe mud houses cracking and collapsing under the vibration of heavy truck traffic and plant operations loud enough to disturb sleep close to midnight. Those accounts now sit against a $210 million financing decision by the institution.

The International Finance Corporation approved the money for that expansion and classifies the project as Category A, its highest environmental and social risk tier. Once its new lines are running, the facility is expected to emit about 4.1 million tonnes of CO₂ a year, 2.9 million of them from the expansion, AllAfrica reported.

Despite that risk rating and that emissions profile, the IFC’s own file sets no reduction target and requires no independent verification of those figures, before approval or since.

The gap between what the file contains and what the label claims is the core of the case now being put to the World Bank’s Board of Executive Directors. The author of the account leads Quest for Growth and Development Foundation in Nigeria, where they work with five communities around the plant, one of them resettled for the expansion.

The IFC says it confirmed “broad community support” for the expansion during a site visit in August 2022. Yet none of the community leaders the foundation’s head spoke with recall being consulted before BUA expanded onto land their families had farmed for generations, AllAfrica reported. The institution’s record says they were consulted; the people it describes say otherwise.

BUA says it supports its host communities through health care, scholarships, and donations. The account published by AllAfrica acknowledges those benefits matter but argues they cannot substitute for consultation before a high-risk project is approved. BUA’s position on the consultation dispute is not recorded in the available reporting.

The emissions figures themselves are not the dispute. The dispute is what the IFC’s published climate methodology permits for a project counted as aligned with the Paris Agreement. Under that methodology, in practice, a promise is sufficient to earn the label.

The reporting frames this as a structural feature rather than a one-off failure at a single plant.

The case for demanding more rests partly on a precedent the IFC set itself. The institution has financed a calcined clay cement plant in Burkina Faso, AllAfrica reported.

Two institutional processes could theoretically settle the question, but neither requires waiting, the reporting argues. The Independent Evaluation Group’s ongoing review of the World Bank Group’s Climate Change Action Plan was requested by the World Bank’s own board this year, with no findings yet public.

The framing offered to the board is deliberately narrow: the request is not that directors take farmers in Nigeria at their word alone, but that they close the gaps the IFC’s own file exposes.

The board doesn’t need to wait for climate to return to the agenda, the argument concludes; it needs a rule that makes the commitment binding and checkable, not a pledge to be resolved later. Whether the draft Sustainability Framework due in the coming weeks imposes verification, a baseline, or an alternatives analysis remains unpublished — and until it appears, the question the IFC’s own file raises stays open.

Photo of author

World Desk

World Desk at Archyde.

Anthropic to Debut Thursday as First Public Frontier AI Lab, IPO Expected to Value Firm Over $1 Trillion